By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - Game of thrones season 6 about to ruin the books? George has "writers block".

 

I am a...

Reader of ASOIAF and will watch the season 6. 24 34.29%
 
Reader of ASOIAF and will NOT watch season 6. 18 25.71%
 
Reader and I just can't decide. 1 1.43%
 
Reader& off to live i... 2 2.86%
 
Viewer of the show. HaHa... 14 20.00%
 
Viewer of the show. scare... 10 14.29%
 
Total:69
binary solo said:
Boutros said:

Most characters have the same direction in the book though..

Jaime, different. Stannis, different. Selyse and Shireen, different. Sansa, different. Myrcella, different. Bronn, different. Brienne, different. Barristan, different. Melissandre, different. Jaime and Cersei's relationship, different. Even the manner of how Jon got to his end point was substantially different.

Barristan Selma being robbed of one of the most bad ass moments in the series. There were many changes all over Westeros and Essos. season five marked the break where the books and shows became distinct entities.

 

That said, I read the books long before the show so as long as those finish before I or George die then I'll be content.



Around the Network
binary solo said:
Boutros said:

Most characters have the same direction in the book though..

Jaime, different. Stannis, different. Selyse and Shireen, different. Sansa, different. Myrcella, different. Bronn, different. Brienne, different. Barristan, different. Melissandre, different. Jaime and Cersei's relationship, different. Even the manner of how Jon got to his end point was substantially different.

They cut so many characters from the book that they have no choice but to change things up (like Sansa taking Jeyne Poole's place).

Stannis was always just a distraction. It was only a matter of time.

Sansa's story started being different in season 4 so it isn't season 5 that really changed things.

What character do you have in mind when you say you don't like their direction?



Boutros said:
binary solo said:

Jaime, different. Stannis, different. Selyse and Shireen, different. Sansa, different. Myrcella, different. Bronn, different. Brienne, different. Barristan, different. Melissandre, different. Jaime and Cersei's relationship, different. Even the manner of how Jon got to his end point was substantially different.

They cut so many characters from the book that they have no choice but to change things up (like Sansa taking Jeyne Poole's place).

Stannis was always just a distraction. It was only a matter of time.

Sansa's story started being different in season 4 so it isn't season 5 that really changed things.

What character do you have in mind when you say you don't like their direction?

Well Barristan was definitely screwed considering he's still alive in the books.



John2290 said:
binary solo said:

Jaime, different. Stannis, different. Selyse and Shireen, different. Sansa, different. Myrcella, different. Bronn, different. Brienne, different. Barristan, different. Melissandre, different. Jaime and Cersei's relationship, different. Even the manner of how Jon got to his end point was substantially different.

you forgot Sams trip to old town, one of the moat drastic changes.

More like his trip to Braavos on the way to Oldtown, which actually sets up a far more compelling set of events leading to Arya ...spoiler? I can't rmember where we ended with Arya in the TV show... than how it plays out in the show. Oh and the poisoning of the oysters, such an amateur method of assassination compared to what she does in the book. But I was half expecting the entire Oldtown plotline to be cut. It adds a whole new cast of characters and a new court of intrigue that the show simply can't accomodate. I wouldn;t be surprised if GRRM is actually having a hard time weaving the Oldtown plot into the wider story himself. I'm really excited to follow Sam's path in Oldtown, but I suspect GRRM is perhaps regretting introducing the citadel this late in the piece. But also having it cut completely from the show is a big spoiler in itself, because it tells us that ultimately the Oldtown plotline has negligible impact on the ultimate conclusion to the story.

Oh, and of course Mance Rayder's path is way different and cut horribly short.

Things actually started to go wonky for me when Robb got the hots for some foreign girl instead of falling for a the daughter of a Lannister ally. I do hope there's a pay off with it seeming like Lady Stoneheart won't be putting in an appearance, and perhaps instead her path of vengeance is trodden by Talisa's family seeking revenge for her murder. She is from one of the ruling families of Volantis after all, and even if she renounced her slaver homeland, she stayed in contact with her family and they will be none too pleased at her being murdered horribly. But I suspect the show won't even bother with that. Indeed it seems possible that other than the immediate aftermath the red wedding will be largely forgotten about, and no one will do anything to try to right those wrongs.



“The fundamental cause of the trouble is that in the modern world the stupid are cocksure while the intelligent are full of doubt.” - Bertrand Russell

"When the power of love overcomes the love of power, the world will know peace."

Jimi Hendrix

 

Well, season 5 was pretty bad and uninteresting, so I don't mind not watching season 6 at all. And series spoilers maybe won't be books spoilers. Too much changes in the last season even with the books released, I'm sure the next season won't follow the future books.



Around the Network

Yeah I feel sorry for the book guys, I'm not into the books or the TV series myself but I know everything that happens basically because people do not keep their mouth shut and it's the fan bases fault.

Heck, if I had never seen breaking bad I could go in not knowing anything because I have never seen anyone spoil the show or its ending. It's unfortunate bot all fan bases are alike.



There's only 2 races: White and 'Political Agenda'
2 Genders: Male and 'Political Agenda'
2 Hairstyles for female characters: Long and 'Political Agenda'
2 Sexualities: Straight and 'Political Agenda'

although the books are simply much better I have no problems watching S6 as it airs