pokoko said:
That's pretty mean to blowup doll-san. It's true, sure, but it's mean.
I had actually typed out that I wish Diane/King were the main characters but then I deleted it. After thinking about it, that would probably make them far less flawed and complicated. I would not want to see them end up like Perfect McShota and blowup doll, where they create a black hole of blandness that taints everything around them.
I know you're a fan of shounen but, for me, 90% of the time, I hate the MC. This is coming from someone who grew up reading fantasy novels all the time. I don't know if it's manga writers or if editors are forcing a stereotype but so few of them are interesting at all. Beyond Luffy, who actually has a unique and likeable personality, there aren't many that I wouldn't like to see fail and get kicked out by another cast member.
|
I like them sometimes, hate them sometimes, like them only in certain situations sometimes...I guess it depends. I admit I find that naivete somewhat infectious, and I like the reckless optimism to an extent. I do like seeing the trope used to drive a more serious point home, like One Piece and Hunter x Hunter touch on with their MCs, for example.
With Meliodas, being uninteresting is part of it, but I also feel like, even more than usual, he comes across as a severe case of author self-insert. He very rarely acts surprised or worried at anything, making it seem like he's never in any actual trouble. He follows the innocent prisoner trope, which means he gets to be both edgy and pure at the same time. His only real quirk is his perverted side, but since the target of his perversion usually acquieses, it feels less like a problem and more like that he's awesome dude that gets the girl whenever he wants. Not to mention that his blow-up doll is basically the perfect submissive waifu that would do anything for him that Japan seems to love. All these things combined, and it just feels like everytime I see him, the author is just screaming, "Hey guys! Check out my MC! Isn't he the best? Girls love him! Bad guys fear him! I bet you wish you were him!"
Woo...that was a lot of venting. I probably spend more time typing about the manga than actually reading it.