By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Predict review scores for Uncharted 4, DOOM, Mirrors Edge Catalyst, and others - VGChartz Metacritic Prediction League - May

Hi everyone, this will be my first thread on VGChartz. I don't know if this has been done before here, but I thought it would be fun to predict the average Metacritic scores for upcoming games. If you want to participate just post the games and your prediction as a score out of 100. Predictions must be made before the games are released and before the first reviews appear on Metacritic. I decided to score points to make this more competitive, and also included negative points. Also feel free to tell why you think the games will get said scores if you make predictions.

Scoring: (For multiplatform games the average of the Metacritic scores will be taken) Update 11th of April: Starting with May, for multiplatform games, a proportional weighted average accoring to the number of reviews, will be used to get the metacritic score here. For more info check the first post on page 8 on this thread, where I explain how the new scoring method works.

  • Predicting exact Metacritic score = +5 points
  • Off by 1 = +4 points
  • Off by 2 = +3 points
  • Off by 3 = +2 points
  • Off by 4 = +1 points
  • Off by 5 = +0 points
  • Off by 6 = -1 points
  • Off by 7 = -2 points
  • Off by 8 = -3 points
  • Off by 9 = -4 points
  • Off by 10 or more = -5 points

I did this same competition on another forum and already did this for February, and started on March however due to very few participants I wanted to try this here as well (Would have done this earlier but had to collect my 50 posts).

Post your metacritic predictions for games of April. Post predictions for at least 3 games (3, 4, 5 or more) from games below. You can also add any other game releasing in the month as long as it's not a remaster, rerelease, port, and doesn't already have a metascore/reviews, I'll add it to the predictions.

Games of March (Predict Metacrtic score for AT LEAST 3 titles, so 3, 4, 5, etc. is fine)

  • Tom Clancy's The Division
  • Hitman: - Episode 1 - Intro
  • EA Sports UFC 2
  • Pokkén Tournament
  • TrackMania Turbo
  • (Any other title you want to predict that's releasing in March, and doesn't have reviews up yet and is not a port/rerelease/remaster)

Games of April (Predict Metacrtic score for AT LEAST 3 titles for April, so 3, 4, 5, etc. is fine)

  • Quantum Break
  • Ratchet & Clank
  • Dark Souls III
  • Star Fox Zero
  • King's Quest Chapter 3
  • (Any other title you want to predict that's releasing in April, and doesn't have reviews up yet and is not a port/rerelease/remaster)

Games of May (Predict Metacrtic score for AT LEAST 5 titles for May, so 5, 6, 7, etc. is fine)

  • Battleborn
  • Uncharted 4: A Thief’s End
  • DOOM
  • Homefront: The Revolution
  • Mirror’s Edge Catalyst
  • Overwatch
  • Total War: WARHAMMER
  • Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Mutants in Manhattan
  • Sherlock Holmes: The Devil’s Daughter
  • (Any other title you want to predict that's releasing in May, and doesn't have reviews up yet and is not a port/rerelease/remaster)
Games of June (To be updated at beginning of May)
  • Resident Evil: Umbrella Corps

Predictions for March (Last updated 3rd of April):

User Game Predicted metacritic score Metacritic score Off By Points
Profrektius Tom Clancy's The Division 79 80 1 +4
iTzCharlie Tom Clancy's The Division 84 80 4 +1
Volterra_90 Tom Clancy's The Division 82 80 2 +3
OdinHades Tom Clancy's The Division 81 80 1 +4
Profrektius Hitman: Intro Pack 77 77 0 +5
iTzCharlie Hitman: Intro Pack 76 77 1 +4
Volterra_90 Hitman: Intro Pack 76 77 1 +4
OdinHades Hitman: Intro Pack 65 77 12 -5
Profrektius EA Sports UFC 2 77 78 1 +4
iTzCharlie EA Sports UFC 2 82 78 4 +1
OdinHades EA Sports UFC 2 77 78 1 +4
Volterra_90 Pokkén Tournament 78 76 2 +3
OdinHades Pokkén Tournament 86 76 10 -5
OdinHades TrackMania Turbo 84 79 5 +0

Predictions for April (Last updated 18th of April):

User Game Predicted metacritic score Metacritic score Off By Points
the_dark_lewd Ratchet & Clank 90 86 4 +1
KingofTrolls Ratchet & Clank 85 86 1 +4
iTzCharlie Ratchet & Clank 79 86 7 -2
AEGRO Ratchet & Clank 86 86 0 +5
axumblade Ratchet & Clank 83 86 3 +2
PEEPer0nni Ratchet & Clank 88 86 2 +3
Swordmasterman Ratchet & Clank 83 86 3 +2
Neoarc Ratchet & Clank 85 86 1 +4
COKTOE Ratchet & Clank 88 86 2 +3
Shikamo Ratchet & Clank 86 86 0 +5
Qwark  Ratchet & Clank 85 86 1 +4
DivinePaladin Ratchet & Clank 87 86 1 +4
Angelv577 Ratchet & Clank 81 86 5 +0
HEMSTAR Ratchet & Clank 83 86 3 +2
binary solo Ratchet & Clank 83 86 3 +2
Profrektius Ratchet & Clank 80 86 6 -1
Wagram Ratchet & Clank 83 86 3 +2
hamo0odi90 Ratchet & Clank 85 86 1 +4
Fear_Me_All Ratchet & Clank 88 86 2 +3
celador Ratchet & Clank 76 86 10 -5
Aerys Ratchet & Clank 83 86 3 +2
Machina Ratchet & Clank 84 86 2 +3
Nemesis1993 Ratchet & Clank 86 86 0 +5
TheGoldenBoy Ratchet & Clank 85 86 1 +4
shikamaru317 Ratchet & Clank 83 86 3 +2
Kagerow Ratchet & Clank 89 86 3 +2
Chasesdaddy84 Ratchet & Clank 87 86 1 +4
Flouff Ratchet & Clank 87 86 1 +4
Cerebralbore101 Ratchet & Clank 85 86 1 +4
the_dark_lewd Dark Souls III 85 88 3 +2
KingofTrolls Dark Souls III 85 88 3 +2
iTzCharlie Dark Souls III 80 88 8 -3
AEGRO Dark Souls III 91 88 3 +2
axumblade Dark Souls III 85 88 3 +2
PEEPer0nni Dark Souls III 84 88 4 +1
Swordmasterman Dark Souls III 88 88 0 +5
Neoarc Dark Souls III 90 88 2 +3
COKTOE Dark Souls III 87 88 1 +4
Shikamo Dark Souls III 91 88 3 +2
Qwark  Dark Souls III 87 88 1 +4
DivinePaladin Dark Souls III 89 88 1 +4
Angelv577  Dark Souls III 91 88 3 +2
HEMSTAR Dark Souls III 90 88 2 +3
binary solo Dark Souls III 90 88 2 +3
Profrektius Dark Souls III 89 88 1 +4
Wagram Dark Souls III 89 88 1 +4
hamo0odi90 Dark Souls III 90 88 2 +3
Fear_Me_All Dark Souls III 89 88 1 +4
celador Dark Souls III 91 88 3 +2
Aerys Dark Souls III 93 88 5 +0
Machina Dark Souls III 88 88 0 +5
Nemesis1993 Dark Souls III 88 88 0 +5
TheGoldenBoy Dark Souls III 90 88 2 +3
shikamaru317 Dark Souls III 90 88 2 +3
Kagerow Dark Souls III 90 88 2 +3
Chasesdaddy84 Dark Souls III 92 88 4 +1
Flouff Dark Souls III 91 88 3 +2
KingofTrolls Quantum Break 91 72 19 -5
iTzCharlie Quantum Break 85 72 13 -5
axumblade Quantum Break 87 72 15 -5
Swordmasterman Quantum Break 84 72 12 -5
AEGRO Quantum Break 86 72 14 -5
Neoarc Quantum Break 83 72 11 -5
COKTOE Quantum Break 88 72 16 -5
Shikamo Quantum Break 81 72 9 -4
Qwark  Quantum Break 89 72 17 -5
Angelv577  Quantum Break 84 72 12 -5
HEMSTAR Quantum Break 86 72 14 -5
binary solo Quantum Break 88 72 16 -5
Profrektius Quantum Break 81 72 9 -4
Wagram Quantum Break 86 72 14 -5
the_dark_lewd Star Fox Zero 80 - - -
iTzCharlie Star Fox Zero 72 - - -
axumblade Star Fox Zero 78 - - -
Swordmasterman Star Fox Zero 91 - - -
AEGRO Star Fox Zero 77 - - -
Neoarc Star Fox Zero 83 - - -
COKTOE Star Fox Zero 86 - - -
Shikamo Star Fox Zero 87 - - -
Qwark  Star Fox Zero 76 - - -
DivinePaladin Star Fox Zero 77 - - -
binary solo Star Fox Zero 75 - - -
Fear_Me_All Star Fox Zero 80 - - -
celador Star Fox Zero 75 - - -
Aerys Star Fox Zero 78 - - -
Machina Star Fox Zero 82 - - -
Nemesis1993 Star Fox Zero 77 - - -
TheGoldenBoy Star Fox Zero 72 - - -
shikamaru317 Star Fox Zero 80 - - -
Kagerow Star Fox Zero 76 - - -
Chasesdaddy84 Star Fox Zero 75 - - -
Flouff Star Fox Zero 82 - - -
Cerebralbore101 Star Fox Zero 83      
hamo0odi90 Star Fox Zero 78      
zwei Star Fox Zero 76      
Profrektius Star Fox Zero 73      
AEGRO King's Quest Chapter 3 70 - - -
Neoarc King's Quest Chapter 3 75 - - -
Fear_Me_All King's Quest Chapter 3 81 - - -
celador King's Quest Chapter 3 80 - - -
TheGoldenBoy King's Quest Chapter 3 71 - - -
Kagerow King's Quest Chapter 3 72 - - -
Cerebralbore101 King's Quest Chapter 3 69      
zwei King's Quest Chapter 3 72      
Profrektius King's Quest Chapter 3 74      

Predictions for May (Last updated 18th of April):

User Game Predicted metacritic score Metacritic score Off By Points
the_dark_lewd Uncharted 4: A Thief’s End 95 - - -
KingofTrolls Uncharted 4: A Thief’s End 92 - - -
iTzCharlie Uncharted 4: A Thief’s End 88 - - -
AEGRO Uncharted 4: A Thief’s End 94 - - -
PEEPer0nni Uncharted 4: A Thief’s End 93 - - -
Neoarc Uncharted 4: A Thief’s End 94 - - -
Qwark Uncharted 4: A Thief’s End 93 - - -
Angelv577  Uncharted 4: A Thief’s End 92 - - -
HEMSTAR Uncharted 4: A Thief’s End 95 - - -
binary solo Uncharted 4: A Thief’s End 91 - - -
hamo0odi90 Uncharted 4: A Thief’s End 96 - - -
Fear_Me_All Uncharted 4: A Thief’s End 97 - - -
celador Uncharted 4: A Thief’s End 87 - - -
Aerys Uncharted 4: A Thief’s End 93 - - -
Machina Uncharted 4: A Thief’s End 94 - - -
Nemesis1993 Uncharted 4: A Thief’s End 95 - - -
TheGoldenBoy Uncharted 4: A Thief’s End 93 - - -
shikamaru317 Uncharted 4: A Thief’s End 93 - - -
Kagerow Uncharted 4: A Thief’s End 91 - - -
Chasesdaddy84 Uncharted 4: A Thief’s End 90 - - -
Flouff Uncharted 4: A Thief’s End 94 - - -
Barkley Uncharted 4: A Thief’s End 92 - - -
Turkish Uncharted 4: A Thief’s End 93      
Shikamo Uncharted 4: A Thief’s End 94      
cesarmgc Uncharted 4: A Thief’s End 96      
Cerebralbore101 Uncharted 4: A Thief’s End 89      
Nate4Drake Uncharted 4: A Thief’s End 94      
zwei Uncharted 4: A Thief’s End 90      
Neoarc DOOM 88 - - -
Qwark DOOM 82 - - -
Angelv577  DOOM 86 - - -
HEMSTAR DOOM 86 - - -
hamo0odi90 DOOM 86 - - -
TheDeleter  DOOM 85 - - -
Fear_Me_All DOOM 77 - - -
celador DOOM 82 - - -
Machina DOOM 82 - - -
Nemesis1993 DOOM 83 - - -
TheGoldenBoy DOOM 88 - - -
shikamaru317 DOOM 88 - - -
Kagerow DOOM 84 - - -
Chasesdaddy84 DOOM 86 - - -
Flouff DOOM 83 - - -
Barkley DOOM 78 - - -
Turkish DOOM 82      
Shikamo DOOM 78      
cesarmgc DOOM 92      
Cerebralbore101 DOOM 79      
Nate4Drake DOOM 88      
zwei DOOM 86      
Neoarc Mirror’s Edge Catalyst 84 - - -
Qwark Mirror’s Edge Catalyst 84 - - -
HEMSTAR Mirror’s Edge Catalyst 81 - - -
hamo0odi90 Mirror’s Edge Catalyst 78 - - -
Fear_Me_All Mirror’s Edge Catalyst 79 - - -
celador Mirror’s Edge Catalyst 81 - - -
Machina Mirror’s Edge Catalyst 81 - - -
Nemesis1993 Mirror’s Edge Catalyst 87 - - -
TheGoldenBoy Mirror’s Edge Catalyst 86 - - -
shikamaru317 Mirror’s Edge Catalyst 84 - - -
Kagerow Mirror’s Edge Catalyst 81 - - -
Chasesdaddy84 Mirror’s Edge Catalyst 82 - - -
Flouff Mirror’s Edge Catalyst 84 - - -
Turkish Mirror’s Edge Catalyst 80      
Shikamo Mirror’s Edge Catalyst 80      
cesarmgc Mirror’s Edge Catalyst 85      
Nate4Drake Mirror’s Edge Catalyst 87      
zwei Mirror’s Edge Catalyst 70      
Neoarc Homefront: The Revolution 80 - - -
Qwark Homefront: The Revolution 72 - - -
HEMSTAR Homefront: The Revolution 72 - - -
Fear_Me_All Homefront: The Revolution 74 - - -
celador Homefront: The Revolution 61 - - -
Machina Homefront: The Revolution 71 - - -
TheGoldenBoy Homefront: The Revolution 79 - - -
shikamaru317 Homefront: The Revolution 70 - - -
Kagerow Homefront: The Revolution 73 - - -
Chasesdaddy84 Homefront: The Revolution 70 - - -
Barkley Homefront: The Revolution 80 - - -
Turkish Homefront: The Revolution 77 - - -
Shikamo Homefront: The Revolution 81      
cesarmgc Homefront: The Revolution 80      
zwei Homefront: The Revolution 65      
Neoarc Battleborn 86 - - -
Fear_Me_All Battleborn 83 - - -
celador Battleborn 83 - - -
Nemesis1993 Battleborn 81 - - -
TheGoldenBoy Battleborn 84 - - -
shikamaru317 Battleborn 77 - - -
Kagerow Battleborn 77 - - -
Flouff Battleborn 87 - - -
Barkley Battleborn 77 - - -
Turkish Battleborn 73      
cesarmgc Battleborn 78      
zwei Battleborn 83      
Neoarc Overwatch 86 - - -
Fear_Me_All Overwatch 83 - - -
celador Overwatch 83 - - -
Nemesis1993 Overwatch 85 - - -
TheGoldenBoy Overwatch 88 - - -
shikamaru317 Overwatch 88 - - -
Kagerow Overwatch 88 - - -
Flouff Overwatch 86 - - -
Barkley Overwatch 86 - - -
Turkish Overwatch 81      
Shikamo Overwatch 90      
cesarmgc Overwatch 83      
Cerebralbore101 Overwatch 90      
zwei Overwatch 85      
Neoarc Total War: WARHAMMER 80 - - -
Fear_Me_All Total War: WARHAMMER 73 - - -
celador Total War: WARHAMMER 76 - - -
Machina Total War: WARHAMMER 80 - - -
TheGoldenBoy Total War: WARHAMMER 74 - - -
Kagerow Total War: WARHAMMER 80 - - -
Barkley Total War: WARHAMMER 79 - - -
Turkish Total War: WARHAMMER 81      
zwei Total War: WARHAMMER 80      
Machina TMNT: Mutants in Manhattan 75 - - -
Shikamo TMNT: Mutants in Manhattan 74      
NeoArc TMNT: Mutants in Manhattan 81      
zwei TMNT: Mutants in Manhattan 70      
NeoArc Sherlock Holmes and Devil's Daughter 78      
zwei Sherlock Holmes and Devil's Daughter 75      

Predictions for June (will update and the games start of May, for now only the delayed game from May is here)

User Game Predicted metacritic score Metacritic score Off By Points
Neoarc Resident Evil: Umbrella Corps 73 - - -
Qwark Resident Evil: Umbrella Corps 74 - - -
Angelv577  Resident Evil: Umbrella Corps 75 - - -
Fear_Me_All Resident Evil: Umbrella Corps 71 - - -
celador Resident Evil: Umbrella Corps 64 - - -
Machina Resident Evil: Umbrella Corps 70 - - -
Nemesis1993 Resident Evil: Umbrella Corps 38 - - -
TheGoldenBoy Resident Evil: Umbrella Corps 70 - - -
Kagerow Resident Evil: Umbrella Corps 72 - - -
Chasesdaddy84 Resident Evil: Umbrella Corps 74 - - -
zwei Resident Evil: Umbrella Corps 75      

Leaderboard for March (Last updated 3rd of April)

Position User Points
1. Profrektius +13
2. Volterra_90 +10
3. iTzCharlie +6
4. OdinHades -2

Leaderboard for April (Last updated 11th of April) (PS. I did not include people who have made less than 3 predictions for April) (PPS. I'll update this once the reviews for SFZ and KQC3 settle, as I am doing this by hand and it is a lot of work)

Position User Points
1. DivinePaladin +9
1. Nemesis1993 +9
1. Shikamo +9
4. Fear_Me_All +8
4. TheGoldenBoy +8
6. Flouff +7
6. Machina +7
6. Neoarc +7
9. Chasesdaddy84 +6
9. Kagerow +6
9. shikamaru317 +6
12. Profrektius +5
13. AEGRO +4
13. Swordmasterman +4
15. Aerys +3
15. Wagram +3
17. HEMSTAR +2
17. Qwark +2
17. the_dark_lewd +2
20. Angelv577 +1
20. binary solo +1
20. COKTOE +1
23. KingofTrolls +0
24. axumblade -2
24. celador -2
26. iTzCharlie -9


Around the Network
So I'll start off with my predictions:
  • Tom Clancy's The Division - 79
  • Hitman: Episode 1 — Intro - 77
  • EA Sports UFC 2 - 77
Remember Tom Clancy's The Division can still be predicted today (until no official review scores are up and they shouldn't be today). Also you should make a minimun of 3 predictions for March (can be more).


No one else is participating/predicting. I'm new to the forums and now I feel very lonely here. :(

Feel free to suggest improvements modifications to this thread if something doesn't seem right.



Tom Clancy's The Division: 84
Hitman: - Episode 1 - Intro: 76
EA Sports UFC 2: 82



Feel free to still predict The Division as it still doesn't have a metacritic score, and there's almost no reviews out there yet.



Around the Network

I'll add one game for the WiiU, Pokkén Tournament if you don't mind ;)

So, based on what I've seen, and how reviewers normally rate games:

The Division: 82
Pokkén Tournament: 78



Volterra_90 said:

I'll add one game for the WiiU, Pokkén Tournament if you don't mind ;)

So, based on what I've seen, and how reviewers normally rate games:

The Division: 82
Pokkén Tournament: 78

Added it. :)

Would you mind predicting one more game though?



Profrektius said:

Added it. :)

Would you mind predicting one more game though?

No problem, though I don't know too much about it xDDD.

Hitman: Episode 1 ---> 76



Ok, I seriously suck at this, but what the hell. =D

The Division: 81
Hitman: - Episode 1 - Intro: 65
EA Sports UFC 2: 77
Pokkén Tournament: 86
TrackMania Turbo: 84



Official member of VGC's Nintendo family, approved by the one and only RolStoppable. I feel honored.

And just in time for Hitman: Intro Pack reviews, as the embargo ended 55 minutes ago and the metascore is at 76/77 now. There are only a few reviews up at the moment and it is yet to change, I have to say that these seem to have been some incredibly accurate predictions here.

Also Ea Sports UFC 2 reviews are coming up today and that is currently at 75 for the Xbox One version.

I will, however, wait until more reviews come in before updating the scores and perhaps making a leaderboards table.