Tough call but I am going for the underdog being Ratchet and Clank. It has the animation style I grew to love, with natural looking metals, lighting etc, combined with cartoony looking enemies and greenery. This combined with PS4 graphics can make a game not only looking amazing but also being able to age well.

I'm going with Undertale 2

Traditionally, on consoles the best graphics are from the exclusives, and I'd give my vote to Uncharted 4 from the ones here. Naughty Dog are known for their ability to push graphics and this should be no exception.

I would have liked to seen Ratchet & Clank on the list to. The art style is different which is why it will probably be left out, but the the game looks amazing.

I think Doom will beast out the graphics since its on pc and on ultra high settings will look like fire.

On consoles, up until yesterday morning I would have made it a draw between uncharted and quantum break, but since the release of the trailer, Uncharted takes it for me.

I would love to see more of Horizon. We've seen very little compared to other games launching this year.

Uncharted 4 is the clear leader to me, it's stunning. Will be the best looking game until God of War 4.

Uncharted 4 certainly looks amazing!
However I've always loved the ME artstyle....
And ROTR looks fantastic too......
And Horizon and Deus Ex won't be easily beaten....
And I have high hopes for FFXV........

idk

Are they going for the miniature look? With that depth of field it looks more like a diorama. Reminds me of 3D dot heroes.
Is that the new way of optimizing things, hide the background detail, everything out of focus! That doesn't qualify as 1080p to me.
(Imagine what the full size version of that image would look like with that dof effect)

OP's titles must bow down to the Ratchet :p

https://youtu.be/--NbhH_K-Ic

Yeah I think Ratchet should be up there. It's personally the best looking ps4 exclusive so far and I would put it above Mirror's edge even, in both style and art direction.

In 10 years, I think most people will think R&C was the best looking title released this year (especially with Zelda U out of the way ), but currently I guess it won't be included in debates about best graphics, if only because it's hard to compare it to the other games.