By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Nintendo Discussion - Do we (customer) really want Zelda Wii U on NX?

 

Do YOU want Zelda Wii U being on NX

Yes, I want it, because... 274 55.58%
 
No, I dont want it, because... 144 29.21%
 
Results 75 15.21%
 
Total:493
Miyamotoo said:

You said so many time and you were wrong every time. Tablet controller is just one of reasons why Wii U failed not only reason.

sorry but you will probl never understand it. The tablet controller was not the reason the wii u failed. The non existence of a popular gimmick (like motion controls) was the reason.

The wiiu named ultra nintendo, released with a pro controller, better marketing and released a new zelda game wouldnt pass 20mio by now either.

 

Miyamotoo said:

What do you think, what sales of Wii would be without Wii Sports and Zelda TP like launch titles, without great price point ($250), without great marketing and with software drouth!?

without wii sports (and motion controls in general): around 10-20 mio

Without twilight princess: 100 Mio.

 

Miyamotoo said:

You comparing youtube views of one of most popular game ever (GTA V) that is multi platform and that is on two genes of consoles, with Zelda game that currently exclusive for worst selling Nintendo console ever!?

your the one acting like zelda wii u will be 100% cross gen, so its cross gen either.

You dont need a wii u to watch a trailer / beeing interested in a game. Thats why wii us sales doesnt matter in terms of youtube sales. It just prooves that zelda isnt as popular as other franchises.

Uncharted 4, also a exclusive game, 9 mio views on trailer: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y1Rx-Bbht5E



Around the Network
curl-6 said:
bigtakilla said:

Fair enough, but a console main Pokemon would more than likely be bigger than both of those titles... Combined.

Ad a new Mario Kart and 2D Mario has a history of selling better than a 3d Mario and 3d Zelda. Just saying there are mulitple ways they could go about a launch that would equal or blow away the sales of a 3d Mario and Zelda.

While you are right in that 3D Mario + Zelda isn't the only strong launch combo, I don't think 2D Mario has much hardware shifting power any more, at least not in its New Super Mario Bros form, which has long since grown stale. 

Also, launching with Mario Kart 9 seems unlikely given that MK8 released less than two years ago, and had DLC to keep the team busy until a year ago.

It was pretty much the only reason to buy a Wii U (NSMBWU), outside of extremely late ports and managed to move a few.



bigtakilla said:

It was pretty much the only reason to buy a Wii U (NSMBWU), outside of extremely late ports and managed to move a few.

Even with Mario Kart 8, Splatoon, Smash, 2 Zelda HD remakes, Zelda Spin Off, 3D Mario, Third party exclusives (bayonetta 2, lego undercover and more), Donkey Kong, Mario Level Editor and alot more the wii u isnt selling significant better.

The exclusive games are not the reason nintendos consoles decreases in sales. 



JNK said:
Wyrdness said:
I don't know where you got your 2D platformer is a better launch option argument from because TP on the Wii sold 7.2m a full 2.2m more then what NSMBU has sold in total, 2d platformers sell to the userbase already there they don't really bring in new people to the userbase. TP sold 500k on it's first day with the Wii for reference.

Twilight princess sold 7mio copies on 100mio installed hw base = 7%attachment rate

NSMBU sold 5Mio ond 12 Mio installed hw base = 40%attachment rate.

 

You really cant be serious if your claiming TP was the better launch title lol. Just compare a 2d mario vs a zelda game on the same plattform.

 

Youtube views are great to compare general interest in a game. In your argumentation, sales are bad as well. 1 person could buy 20 copies of a game, where another person just buys 1. That argumentation doesnt make even a little bit sense.

Wii didn't have 100m people at launch did it, TP not only moved more hardware at launch then NSMBU it helped in giving the platform high momentum something that you can't argue here. 2D Mario is not a system seller and NSMBU has proven that, it's a game that sells to people already there.

Youtube views have no substance in an argument, they're often a desperate argument people turn to, 1m people can watch a video 20 times each giving it 20m views while 3m people can watch another video once giving it 3m views yet more people watched the latter, it's simple flaws like this that highlight why it's a weak argument.



JNK said:
Miyamotoo said:

You said so many time and you were wrong every time. Tablet controller is just one of reasons why Wii U failed not only reason.

sorry but you will probl never understand it. The tablet controller was not the reason the wii u failed. The non existence of a popular gimmick (like motion controls) was the reason.

The wiiu named ultra nintendo, released with a pro controller, better marketing and released a new zelda game wouldnt pass 20mio by now either.

 

Miyamotoo said:

What do you think, what sales of Wii would be without Wii Sports and Zelda TP like launch titles, without great price point ($250), without great marketing and with software drouth!?

without wii sports (and motion controls in general): around 10-20 mio

Without twilight princess: 100 Mio.

 

Miyamotoo said:

You comparing youtube views of one of most popular game ever (GTA V) that is multi platform and that is on two genes of consoles, with Zelda game that currently exclusive for worst selling Nintendo console ever!?

your the one acting like zelda wii u will be 100% cross gen, so its cross gen either.

You dont need a wii u to watch a trailer / beeing interested in a game. Thats why wii us sales doesnt matter in terms of youtube sales. It just prooves that zelda isnt as popular as other franchises.

Uncharted 4, also a exclusive game, 9 mio views on trailer: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y1Rx-Bbht5E

I know you refer gamepad to gimmick, again not popular gimmick isnt only reason why Wii U failed.

You just keep dening that things like bad launch titles, bad marketing and name, high price, software drouth...didnt had any impact on Wii U sales. And yes without those mistakes Wii U would easily pass 20m, just good and not misunderstood marketing would push Wii U above 20m.

 

You didnt answer my quesition, what do you think, what sales of Wii would be without Wii Sports and Zelda TP like launch titles, without great price point ($250), without great marketing and with software drouth!? Without all that combine, because Wi had all that while Wii U didn't had any of those things. Saying that TP like launch title didn't had any impact on Wii sales is also dening, because that is game that bringed core gamers to platform not Wii Sports.

Interesting, you think that every Nintendo console (expect Wii) will be in decline, thats why you think Wii U wouldn't pass 20m because GC sold 23m and going same path Wii U would need to sell less, but you cant predict things like that, its very simple, if product is good and apoeling it will sell, if you have bad product that isn't appealing (like Wii U) it will not sell.

 

Zelda U officially don't be cross gen until Nintendo say its cross gen, IMO that is almost certain, but that doesnt have nothing with comparing youtube views, lol.

When you actually have console or you plan to buy one you will definitely be far more interesting for games for that console than somebody who dont have that console and dont have plans to buy it. That is a fact.

Again bad comparison, Uncharted 4 is game on platform that has user base is around 3x time larger than Wii Us, Uncharted have 9m views while Zelda U has 4.7m views with 3x smaller userbase.



Around the Network
Wyrdness said:

I don't know where you got your 2D platformer is a better launch option argument from because TP on the Wii sold 7.2m a full 2.2m more then what NSMBU has sold in total, 2d platformers sell to the userbase already there they don't really bring in new people to the userbase. TP sold 500k on it's first day with the Wii for reference.

Wii sold better because of one thing that didn't happen with Wii U, it was handled better from launch, marketing, pricing, bundling etc... This speaks volumes when for 2 years people thought Wii U was an add on for the Wii and not a new console

 

Wyrdness said:
JNK said:

Twilight princess sold 7mio copies on 100mio installed hw base = 7%attachment rate

NSMBU sold 5Mio ond 12 Mio installed hw base = 40%attachment rate.

 

You really cant be serious if your claiming TP was the better launch title lol. Just compare a 2d mario vs a zelda game on the same plattform.

 

Youtube views are great to compare general interest in a game. In your argumentation, sales are bad as well. 1 person could buy 20 copies of a game, where another person just buys 1. That argumentation doesnt make even a little bit sense.

Wii didn't have 100m people at launch did it, TP not only moved more hardware at launch then NSMBU it helped in giving the platform high momentum something that you can't argue here. 2D Mario is not a system seller and NSMBU has proven that, it's a game that sells to people already there.

 

Totally agree, all you wrote are facts, especially part about Wii and Wii U sales comparison, but JNK just keep denying those facts.



Miyamotoo said:
Thunderbird77 said:

Problem is your idea isn't even based on any evidence, yet you keep talking about it as if it's already confirmed. You're not saying things like "I think it will be...". You're saying "It WILL be like that".

Like, I wrote, my idea is based on Nintendo talk. Of Course that nothing is not confirmed until Nintendo confirmed.

Your ideas are based on YOUR interpretation of nintendo talk. And while you're entitled to it, the problem is how you always talks as if those are confirmed things.



Miyamotoo said:
JNK said:

sorry but you will probl never understand it. The tablet controller was not the reason the wii u failed. The non existence of a popular gimmick (like motion controls) was the reason.

The wiiu named ultra nintendo, released with a pro controller, better marketing and released a new zelda game wouldnt pass 20mio by now either.

 

without wii sports (and motion controls in general): around 10-20 mio

Without twilight princess: 100 Mio.

 

your the one acting like zelda wii u will be 100% cross gen, so its cross gen either.

You dont need a wii u to watch a trailer / beeing interested in a game. Thats why wii us sales doesnt matter in terms of youtube sales. It just prooves that zelda isnt as popular as other franchises.

Uncharted 4, also a exclusive game, 9 mio views on trailer: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y1Rx-Bbht5E

I know you refer gamepad to gimmick, again not popular gimmick isnt only reason why Wii U failed.

You just keep dening that things like bad launch titles, bad marketing and name, high price, software drouth...didnt had any impact on Wii U sales. And yes without those mistakes Wii U would easily pass 20m, just good and not misunderstood marketing would push Wii U above 20m.

 

You didnt answer my quesition, what do you think, what sales of Wii would be without Wii Sports and Zelda TP like launch titles, without great price point ($250), without great marketing and with software drouth!? Without all that combine, because Wi had all that while Wii U didn't had any of those things. Saying that TP like launch title didn't had any impact on Wii sales is also dening, because that is game that bringed core gamers to platform not Wii Sports.

Interesting, you think that every Nintendo console (expect Wii) will be in decline, thats why you think Wii U wouldn't pass 20m because GC sold 23m and going same path Wii U would need to sell less, but you cant predict things like that, its very simple, if product is good and apoeling it will sell, if you have bad product that isn't appealing (like Wii U) it will not sell.

 

Zelda U officially don't be cross gen until Nintendo say its cross gen, IMO that is almost certain, but that doesnt have nothing with comparing youtube views, lol.

When you actually have console or you plan to buy one you will definitely be far more interesting for games for that console than somebody who dont have that console and dont have plans to buy it. That is a fact.

Again bad comparison, Uncharted 4 is game on platform that has user base is around 3x time larger than Wii Us, Uncharted have 9m views while Zelda U has 4.7m views with 3x smaller userbase.

Wii U didn't have high price and bad launch games, it did have a game drought right after launch. Also, ps4 and x1 weren't affected by bad launch games and high price.



Thunderbird77 said:
Miyamotoo said:

Like, I wrote, my idea is based on Nintendo talk. Of Course that nothing is not confirmed until Nintendo confirmed.

Your ideas are based on YOUR interpretation of nintendo talk. And while you're entitled to it, the problem is how you always talks as if those are confirmed things.

Of course, and your ideas are based on your interpretation of nintendo talk. Of Course that nothing is not confirmed until Nintendo confirmes. I always talk that those things are almost certain (not confirmed), same you saying that NX isn't unified platform and that Zelda U does not coming on NX, difference is you have nothing to back up that, while I have.



Thunderbird77 said:
Miyamotoo said:

I know you refer gamepad to gimmick, again not popular gimmick isnt only reason why Wii U failed.

You just keep dening that things like bad launch titles, bad marketing and name, high price, software drouth...didnt had any impact on Wii U sales. And yes without those mistakes Wii U would easily pass 20m, just good and not misunderstood marketing would push Wii U above 20m.

 

You didnt answer my quesition, what do you think, what sales of Wii would be without Wii Sports and Zelda TP like launch titles, without great price point ($250), without great marketing and with software drouth!? Without all that combine, because Wi had all that while Wii U didn't had any of those things. Saying that TP like launch title didn't had any impact on Wii sales is also dening, because that is game that bringed core gamers to platform not Wii Sports.

Interesting, you think that every Nintendo console (expect Wii) will be in decline, thats why you think Wii U wouldn't pass 20m because GC sold 23m and going same path Wii U would need to sell less, but you cant predict things like that, its very simple, if product is good and apoeling it will sell, if you have bad product that isn't appealing (like Wii U) it will not sell.

 

Zelda U officially don't be cross gen until Nintendo say its cross gen, IMO that is almost certain, but that doesnt have nothing with comparing youtube views, lol.

When you actually have console or you plan to buy one you will definitely be far more interesting for games for that console than somebody who dont have that console and dont have plans to buy it. That is a fact.

Again bad comparison, Uncharted 4 is game on platform that has user base is around 3x time larger than Wii Us, Uncharted have 9m views while Zelda U has 4.7m views with 3x smaller userbase.

Wii U didn't have high price and bad launch games, it did have a game drought right after launch. Also, ps4 and x1 weren't affected by bad launch games and high price.

Wii U had high price in comparison with PS3/Xbox360, same games looked and worked worse on Wii U than on PS3/360, so you having consumers asking why I would pay around $100 more for console that is weaker than those older and cheaper ones!? Wii U price was high, even Nintendo said that price was higher than they wanted.

People on first place buy Nintendo consoles for Nintendo games, and if you dont have good and strong Nintendo game available there is no need to buy Nintendo console, on other hand people buy PS4/X1 because 3rd party games on first place, thats huge difference. Nintendo needs strong launch exclusives, PS/X dont need. Wii U had very bad launch title (Nintendo Land and NSMB HD, lol).