And the winners are: 

Rocket league (PS4/PC)

The beginners guide (PC)

Until Dawn (PS4)

Downwell (PC/iOS/Android)

Bloodborne (PS4)

The order 1886!(Oh Jim :P)

Undertale (PC)

PC & PS4 the big winners.  2 PC exclusives,  2 PS4 exclusives and 1 PC/PS4 & PC/mobile exclusive.  

https://youtube.com/watch?v=S2TNk10uC5E

The Witcher 3, Splatoon and Xenoblade Chronicles X also got honorable mentions.

Downwell is not a PC exclusive.

Sorry I thought it was.  What else is it on? 

They are his 6 games of the year.  he doesn't just pick one. 

iOS.

Also, it seems like Jim Sterling likes his indie games.

Yeah he's a true gamer.  He doesn't let the indie tag put off his enjoyment of an excellent game.  He gives credit where it's due. Fair play to him!

Until Dawn? Even though Sterling works himself into a slobbering rage over anything from David Cage? That's interesting.

He and everyone else is dubbing the game "the best David Cage game that's not by David Cage". Basically it's a David Cage game in good. Also he's very into cheesy Horror so it's a given.

Seems legit. I honestly love this guy, and he's very passionate about games. I still have to play Until Dawn and Bloodborne, but I think I'd love them because of I've seen of them. The rest of the games are, probably, in my own GOTY list.