One is a PS exclusive, thus it must obviously be better. That's the logic I am noticing. 

We're all getting very close to crossing that "shooting the messenger" rule.  Tread lighlty.

I don't know if people realize the consistently high quality of the 3d Zelda games. I seriously doubt that Horizon will have a higher review average than Zelda U, especially considering these are the people that made the bland Killzone Shadowfall. They have a lot to prove, even with the addition of some devs from other studios.

A games previews/look does not always equate to a good game; just look at the Order and almost all other hyped games.

Tell us how many dungeos does Zelda HD had.

OP, sales and metacritic is not set as you have not counting the speculated NX version. Twilight Princess sold 7.5M on Wii and 1.5M on NGC, and HZD doesn't look like a 9M game. Graphically we can agree who wins, but aesthetically comes to a sobjective opinion.

Wind waker HD > Horizon Zero Dawn :P

1. Thats your opinion.

2. Please make a thread about Horizon Zero Dawn vs Scalebound by yourself.

Using my common sense I can see this game coming in Wii U (as of now). Or shall I count Horizon Zero Dawn PS5 version? We are talking about present mate.

I don't see coming to Wii U using my common sense and my superior knowledge on Zelda and Nintendo development. Guess who is more informed to make an educate prediction.

Metacritic is not important anymore
Zelda will have excellent score
Horizon dont know

"Better" or "Best" is a matter of subjective to be very honest. But man, Horizon Zero Dawn def a more interesting game TO ME than Zelda. Not becuz it's a PS4 exclusive, but becuz of THE game. Even if this is an Xbox One exclusive. I would highly considered to get an xbox for the 1st time just for this! That's how hype i am for this game :D!
So yeah, i really wish it won't be a flop. Horizon Zero Dawn could very well be the next big thing for PlayStation like the Last of Us.