I totally disagree , as the world of Zelda U is Crowded Dungeons more creative than the other Horizon appears to be repetitive with little variety of enemies and few Boss Battle in the historic also we know that the studio behind Zelda is also very more competent that Guerrilla Games

My Opinion

Metacritic: Zelda U > Horizon Zero Dawn

Sales:Zelda Wii U version + Nx Version > Horizon Zero Dawn

Graphics: Horizon Zero Dawn > Zelda

Yeah, as long as Guerrilla gets this right they could have an amazing game on their hands. Graphics and sales I think are an easy win simply because it's PS4 vs. Wii U, but critical reception will be interesting to see.

Graphic-wise it really depends on what Nintendo choses to use for Zelda U, the game awards 2014 footage showed a more realistic world while the latest direct footage (that isn't confirmed to be gameplay ) looked a lot more cartoony.
If they chose to go the cartoony way they simply can't be compared, if they kept the realistic world as of now we can't give an opinion since it's been more than a year since we last saw Zelda U...

for Metacritic I really don't see a new IP defeating the latest entry in one of the most critically aclaimed series ever...

Talking about sales instead I can see Horizion Zero Dawn selling more, but IF Zelda U gets the TP treatment I think it might have a chance...

Yes, you do need to play both games to know which one is better. You can say you think it's going to be better, but it is far, far too early to make a statement claimaing one of them is better than the other.

Same thing as I said to Dr. Vita, it's way too early to make claims like you're making. How do you know the Dungeons in Zelda U are both creative and plentiful? We've also only seen one gameplay section of Horizon, how would you know anything about the variety of enemies or world?

Sales and Graphics, Horizon has the advantage due to bigger install base and better performing console. Critical reception, Horizon, being a new IP has a lot to prove. Zelda usually score in the high 80s to low 90s and has the nostalgia/established franchise factor going into to.

We need to see way more from Zelda U to make good judgement but right now, Horizon looks miles ahead of Zelda U in terms of everything.

Zelda u > horizon - meta
Horizon > zelda u - sales

Simply the history of the Zelda games (fantastic Dungeons and I doubt that this new Zelda different) beyond that Nintendo has quite delaying the game for sure she's preparing something very different, about the guerrillas history does not help much , all killzones had little variety of enemy (of course that is just a guess as the horizon may have repetitive enemies all be through robotic or can not you heads wide variety too, just as they spoke to the zelda world is empty I think I can argue my point of view about Horizon enemies right kk ) even though Killzone 2 is fantastic and the 3 and the mercenary is good games no arrives at the level of a Zelda ever created for home consoles until today so I think Zelda has a lot more likely to be an incredible game than Horizon.

wait wut? High 80s to low 90s? Surely your not comparing like handheld zelda games to mainline 3D zelda games? Surely not? They basically two differant franchises so differant is there gameplay.

First of all, the game has nothing a-like with Zelda other than both protagonist use bow and arrow. So a comparison make absolutely no sense or what so ever, lol!

If you want real comparison, make Horizon Zero Dawn v. Scalebound.