I just checked their site, and it said it was out of stock so you must have ordered the last one.  Those NIS America Limited Edition are rarities.  Keep it if you can afford to. Worst case scanario if you're willing to go through the trouble, sell it on ebay or Amazon.  I think I understand where you are coming from.  I have the first four Atelier games on the PS3 plus the Plus version of Rorona.  And there is no physical release of Totori plus and Meruru Plus, but you can get those via PSN.  Also, I just pre-ordered Atelier Escha & Logy Plus.  I try to obtain and enjoy the "best" version of a game that I can get my hands on, and I mean that literally in which I prefer a physical copy over just digital.  So it's possible that Atelier Shallie Plus might not get a physical release.  Best case scenario if money isn't an object is to keep what you just ordered, and later purchase and enjoy the Plus verion physical or digital, your choice.

I have the Rorona, Totori, and Meruru LEs. I just bought Rorona Plus on PS3.

I have Escha & Logy Plus LE preordered and Shallie LE PS3 waiting. I just need to get Ayesha Plus, which I've been waiting for a Vita sale.

I'm a long time supporter of NISA (back when their store was Rosenqueen), so I do love to support them. I just feel like I'm wasting cash.

Vita is immortal

I truly think that NIS America knows their fanbase and what they want.  That in itself is GOOD.  At least in regards to the Atelier series, their Limited Editions and Limited Edition Plus versions are priced reasonably.  The "problem" is that they have so many of them.  FYI, I did heard that there will be a Black Friday Sale on the PSN which will include Atelier Totori Plus.  I'll be checking it out.  good luck with your decision.

Off topic: I received Tokyo Abyss LE and Danganronpa Another Episode: Ultra Despair Girls LE just yesterday in the mail.  Along with that was the Deadly Premonition: The Director's Cut - Classified Edition.  Good stuff.  And NIS Amierca knows how to package their stuff.

Now all we need is localization :D

The vita has so many RPGs... insane.

Well, you'll be right on all of them reaching here. Why can't I see them in store shelves though... @_@ If I get more of the Atelier games, I'll need to think on which platform I want more haha.