By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Bold Prediction: Uncharted 4 won't be as good as Rise of the Tomb Raider (Metacritic)

MTZehvor said:
S.T.A.G.E. said:


This is a first because we've never seen ND work on a Uncharted with this much power as they've always wanted to. The adventure will be much larger and as will be the gaming world. We will see how it all goes.

The same can be said for any first iteration of a series on new hardware, and, far more often than not, it doesn't lead to a drastically bigger game world or adventure. Those usually come later in a console's lifetime, when the developers have a better grasp of what the hardware is capable of.


No. They had stated long ago that the PS3 hardware was holding them back. I always thought it was a bold statement, but these guys were considered magicians for putting so much into a linear single player experience. Naughty Dog should be given the benefit of the doubt given their pedigree. Unlike most other franchises Sony and Naughty Dog feel confident in their ability to create new franchises that they can let Uncharted go. The same cannot be said for their competitiors and that includes Square with Crystal Dynamics.



Around the Network

Lmfao! Well, everything can happen tbh ;). I remember when Everybody think Fallout 4 is gonna be the best game of this year and even Decade! Too much hype can destroy the game as well... so yeah, nothing is immpossible. That's why im kinda afraid right now.



Xbox Magacine will give it a 10/100, but i expect a 94 anyways.

Dude, look at the Gameplay

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zL46dpNEPPA

it has multiplayer, better graphics, better directed, better story, better animations, better cutscenes, better sales 10:1,  better everything.

RoTR is a good game, but really your Post should be, WAS IT A DAMN MISTAKE TO RELEASE IT ONLY ON XBOX?.

It doesnt get the sales that deserve the game. if i am a RoTR Developer and i see my marketing team make stupid decisions like that, really i would be pissed, i did so much afford and work in it and it doesnt get the reward for it. After Uncharted 4 this game will be outdated, 1 year old game that nobody wants anymore.  Did you play The Last of Us? Dude.. i think when you finish the Game you should reconsider your post

 

meta

UC 1 88, UC2 96!!!!, UC3 92!!!  UC ND 86!

i predict a over 90 rating. 

Both Tomb Raider 85/86, so? 



hentaihinata said:

Xbox Magacine will give it a 10/100, but i expect a 94 anyways.

Dude, look at the Gameplay

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zL46dpNEPPA

it has multiplayer, better graphics, better directed, better story, better animations, better cutscenes, better sales 10:1,  better everything.

RoTR is a good game, but really your Post should be, WAS IT A DAMN MISTAKE TO RELEASE IT ONLY ON XBOX?.

It doesnt get the sales that deserve the game. if i am a RoTR Developer and i see my marketing team make stupid decisions like that, really i would be pissed, i did so much afford and work in it and it doesnt get the reward for it. After Uncharted 4 this game will be outdated, 1 year old game that nobody wants anymore.  Did you play The Last of Us? Dude.. i think when you finish the Game you should reconsider your post

 

meta

UC 1 88, UC2 96!!!!, UC3 92!!!  UC ND 86!

i predict a over 90 rating. 

Both Tomb Raider 85/86, so? 


Microsoft screwed this game because they have no Uncharted of their own. Phil Spencer admitted it. He's a big fan of Uncharted and saw moneyhatting Tomb Raider as an opportunity. 



Considering that one E3 demo of Uncharted was heads above anything we've seen on TR to date on videos... I'll be surprised if it reviews worse than TR. It's just another level, while TR seems to be just a slightly more improved TR game (and don't get me wrong I loved the last TR, it was great). I just don't think the scale and scope are anywhere near each other.



Making an indie game : Dead of Day!

Around the Network

Metacritic be damned. The is the magic word: "won't be as good as".

I can see this thread necro'd once UC4 hits the market. LOL!



RoTR already lost when it scored below 90.

Play U4 first and then decide if it's not as good, but better that RoTR.



“Ore no... Kachi da!”


peterdavid12345 said:

Lmfao! Well, everything can happen tbh ;). I remember when Everybody think Fallout 4 is gonna be the best game of this year and even Decade! Too much hype can destroy the game as well... so yeah, nothing is immpossible. That's why im kinda afraid right now.

Fallout *is* currently the best game of the year :D

I dont think it will be of the decade, thats stretching it. FO4 is amazing, but it has some issues that prevent it being a modern day gaming classic, which is a shame. The base building (and assigning people to it) is just too much of a hassle.



Making an indie game : Dead of Day!

Madword said:
peterdavid12345 said:

Lmfao! Well, everything can happen tbh ;). I remember when Everybody think Fallout 4 is gonna be the best game of this year and even Decade! Too much hype can destroy the game as well... so yeah, nothing is immpossible. That's why im kinda afraid right now.

Fallout *is* currently the best game of the year :D

I dont think it will be of the decade, thats stretching it. FO4 is amazing, but it has some issues that prevent it being a modern day gaming classic, which is a shame. The base building (and assigning people to it) is just too much of a hassle.


On Metacritic, the top three GOTY contenders are MGS5, Witcher 3 and Bloodborne.



S.T.A.G.E. said:
Madword said:

Fallout *is* currently the best game of the year :D

I dont think it will be of the decade, thats stretching it. FO4 is amazing, but it has some issues that prevent it being a modern day gaming classic, which is a shame. The base building (and assigning people to it) is just too much of a hassle.


On Metacritic, the top three GOTY contenders are MGS5, Witcher 3 and Bloodborne.

Well yeah I was talking personally..... Also I think MGS5 got a bit of a let off just because of all the Konami crap (from what I've heard about the annoying game play aspect that really didnt have an impact on the scores, I will probably get it at xmas).

If I was to pick one that wasnt FO4, then I think it would probably be W3.



Making an indie game : Dead of Day!