By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - The Witcher 3 vs Fallout 4 - Gameplaywise

 

Which game has the better gameplay?

Fallout 4 67 29.39%
 
The Witcher 3 160 70.18%
 
Total:227
Skullwaker said:
John2290 said:

There us a clear answer, fallout 4 isn't even close to the quality of The witCher 3.

Opinions are a thing.


You don't say.



Around the Network
Hynad said:

You don't say.

I do say. And, in fact, said.



Official Tokyo Mirage Sessions #FE Thread

                                      

Witcher 3 is the best game I've ever played. Better than Ocarina of time.



Id like to add somethign to this discussion, what classifys as gameplay on a massive open world RPG game ? Cause its not Mario you know, these games arent about getting to the end of the level and killing the boss, there are liek 1 million layers to them, I find it rather unfair to say Fallouts and The Witchers gameplay is how Geralt and the Sole Survivor move on screen. Things like quest structure, character interactions even how the dialogue trees work are all part of the gameplay of a game liek this.



SvennoJ said:
Fallout 4 keeps going strong, still surprising me while TW3 had already fallen into a familiar routine. Granted, I'm going very slow as I keep distracting myself with building stuff. Without the settlement building it might have fallen into routine too.


Had a first sincere laugh in this game with KL-E-O today, though USS Constitution was somewhat decent.



Around the Network
HoloDust said:
SvennoJ said:
Fallout 4 keeps going strong, still surprising me while TW3 had already fallen into a familiar routine. Granted, I'm going very slow as I keep distracting myself with building stuff. Without the settlement building it might have fallen into routine too.


Had a first sincere laugh in this game with KL-E-O today, though USS Constitution was somewhat decent.


It certainly has its moments, another one for me was when I fought the raiders who spoke Norwegian (with ridiculous accents).



Mummelmann said:
HoloDust said:

Had a first sincere laugh in this game with KL-E-O today, though USS Constitution was somewhat decent.


It certainly has its moments, another one for me was when I fought the raiders who spoke Norwegian (with ridiculous accents).


Haha, haven't met them yet...as for accent, let me guess, instead of sounding like Thor Gunderson in Hell on Wheels, they sound like Swedish Chef from original Muppets?

Anyway, still playing it, if you forget that you're supposed to be playing RPG set in Fallout universe, and instead accept that you're playing FPS set in sort of-kind of-looks like, but not exactly feels like Fallout universe, then it's fairly decent experience....I guess somewhere around 3.5/5 to 4/5 stars, which would be from 65/100 to 85/100, depending on particular aspect of the game.



witcher 3 gameplay hands down . Fallout 4 gameplay has no depth as all you can do is shoot like a fps game and vats which is based more on luck than anything else. Reading the comments here, if witcher 3 gameplay is repetitive then FO4 one is even worse



dane007 said:
witcher 3 gameplay hands down . Fallout 4 gameplay has no depth as all you can do is shoot like a fps game and vats which is based more on luck than anything else. Reading the comments here, if witcher 3 gameplay is repetitive then FO4 one is even worse

You may be on to something. VATS does mix up the shooter formula a little though.



It's been a while since I just sat somewhere and admired the emergent AI. I never assigned a main building to my settlement, yet after the work day is over they all like to come together in the community area of my hotel. Using the stoves, bar or sit on the couches and at the tables. It's getting quite a lively settlement. Except for one thing, nobody talks unless I talk to them. Then as if they all telepathically agree they all get up one after the other to go to their different houses to sleep or go upstairs in my hotel. Some night dwellers stick around.

Btw one big difference in the game play is, you switch weapons a lot in F4, whatever is most effective, long medium range, close quarters, rapid fire, stealth high damage, melee to save ammo. You can use vats to take your time, aim yourself for better damage at the risk of getting rushed, use a robot to help you, lead your enemy into a group of feral ghouls or vice versa. You have the spells to mix things up a bit in TW3 yet pretty much a sword is a sword and the crossbows don't differentiate a lot. TW3 became sort of a set dance routine, side step, hit, side step, hit, spell, side step, hit etc. F4 is a lot more dynamic. It was fun finding the perfect 'dance routine' for each category of monster, yet it mostly comes down to what spell to insert in the routine.