By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Website Topics - Copying and Pasting Full Articles in Forum Posts

This is something that has been bothering me for awhile now, and the more copy and pasted articles I see, the worse it gets.

The Problem:
Since I started regularly browsing the forum on VGChartz, I've noticed a peculiar trend in news reporting. People will find a news piece and will blatantly copy and paste the whole thing, images and all, generally fairly lazily, leaving broken images or otherwise, into a forum post and call it good. On a formatting note, it just tends to look awful. On a more serious note, you are blatantly stealing somebody's writing and depriving their website of traffic when you do this. Maybe it's harder to understand the full impact of this when you haven't actually written for a site, but whether it is news or otherwise, when a piece is written, it is written for that site and that site only. If you want to read that piece, you are supposed to go to that site. Depending on the piece, you may rob a site of hundreds of views because there is no longer reason to visit the page in question when literally the entire content, word for word, is pasted right into the forum post. That also means depriving a site of ad revenue, and overall having some level of impact on the site's overall performance.

Essentially, copying and pasting whole articles is lazy and unethical at the best of times. On one hand, you acknowledge a site when you choose them to report news, but then you immediately gut punch them when you take away their traffic.

The Solution:
Having done my share of news reporting on another forum in the past that experienced this same issue for a time, the solution is a simple one. You write a summary of the news in your own words. No copying and pasting. You just make an effort to relay the general idea and direct people to the source for more information if they want or need it. Writers out there, whether you're praising, debating, or berating their pieces, would not be okay with their work being copied and pasted word for word anywhere, a source URL that nobody actually has any reason to click anymore or not.

As a good lesson, adding a source link isn't a magical pass to copying and pasting absolutely anything you want to. Some discretion always has to be taken.

Honestly, I see this is as a somewhat major issue. The current practice for forum news reporting is simply not okay.

As an example of the solution, though, it's just a Kickstarter update:

Allison Road Kickstarter Cancelled, Partnered with Team17

If you aren't faimilar with it, Allison Road is a horror game project that works to bring back horror elements from games such as Silent Hill. It was looking very interesting and like it could be one of the best horror games ever made, but it was uncertain if the Kickstarter would actually be funded in time. In a fortunate turn of events, Kickstarter became unnecessary as Team17, known for their Worms games, partnered with the independent studio working on Allison Road so that hopefully the development team is able to create the game that matches their vision.

To note, it seems that the team is just under the Team17 label. It does not seem like the regular Team17 development team will actually be involved in the project in a way that would hinder the original vision.

Source: Kickstarter Update



 

Around the Network

But.. That would require effort.. This site isn't giving me enough to actually put any effort into the threads.. If i could get away with:"Big PS4 news" and then "see title thread" i would do it..



 

Face the future.. Gamecenter ID: nikkom_nl (oh no he didn't!!) 

NiKKoM said:
But.. That would require effort.. This site isn't giving me enough to actually put any effort into the threads.. If i could get away with:"Big PS4 news" and then "see title thread" i would do it..

Then don't make threads. This is a really shitty excuse for poor reporting practices.



 

Yeah, I came from another forum to this forum because they changed their policies on posting full articles. I think they have about 20 members now.

There's nothing wrong with it so stop trying to create a problem where there isn't one. You joined this year and post 4 times a day on average. Since your time here you have contribution in terms of threads has been 2 (this being your second). It really grinds my gears when people like you turn up and start complaining in a well established forum.



 

The PS5 Exists. 


GribbleGrunger said:

Yeah, I came from another forum to this forum because they changed their policies on posting full articles. I think they have about 20 members now.

There's nothing wrong with it so stop trying to create a problem where there isn't one.

Wow. Your cause and effect reasoning skills are superb...ly awful. Clearly that forum had far more problems than that single policy. Forums live and die. Some have shorter lifespans than others. If you want a counter example, the forum I came from that created a policy against this has more members than it did previously. Does that mean the policy magically increased member count? No. Thanks for playing, though.

And yes, there is a problem. To draw a relevant comparison:

We tend to be against piracy as it deprives the creators of a given material potential profit and appreciation for their work to some degree. So why is copying and pasting a full article from another site okay when it deprives the creators of the given material potential profit and appreciation for their work? Some sites pay their writers based on views, others based on the amount of ad revenue they are receiving. No matter which one you pick, the writer loses out because someone was lazy.



 

Around the Network

Yes, I never read them.



My Etsy store

My Ebay store

Deus Ex (2000) - a game that pushes the boundaries of what the video game medium is capable of to a degree unmatched to this very day.

Should we also disable adblock?



I get where the OP is coming from. However on the flip side, its not a forum members job to drive traffic for websites and the purpose of a thread is to generate discussion not drive ad revenues.

Personally I go with take the extract you want to discuss, link the full article for further reading if users want to. But I highly doubt it would drive more traffic to articles because, have you seen the number of people who post in here purely from topic titles without reading a word of the OP?



RIP Dad 25/11/51 - 13/12/13. You will be missed but never forgotten.

Here's your ONE thread contribution since you joined on the 25th of January this year:

http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/thread.php?id=208745&page=1

Two Tweets.



 

The PS5 Exists. 


You left out the most important thing from the OP



 

Face the future.. Gamecenter ID: nikkom_nl (oh no he didn't!!)