By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Name a Sonic game that YOU like, but everybody else hates

I've been watching a lot of "SomeCallMeJohnny" reviews, and specifically the abundance of sonic games he has reviewed. I am not even a huge Sonic fan, but of course I am always open to play through a Sonic game when I have the chance. It got me thinking about all the bad Sonic games, which most of the time I agree with them being in poor quality, but there is one "bad" sonic game I actually quite like. 

That game would be Sonic and the Black Knight. It is for sure not an infamous Sonic game, but it is still has recieved poor opinions from most people who play it. I for some reason enjoyed this game a lot, though. TI mean, the story is garbage, and the wii-motion controls are a bit awkward, but I still for whatever reaosn like the game.

Any Sonic games that most hate that you like? No answer is wrong unless it's Sanic Boom



Around the Network

A lot of people hated Sonic Lost World, but I liked it enough (the Wii U version at least).

Sure, it had some gimmicky level design, but it's a pretty decent 3D platformer.



Official Tokyo Mirage Sessions #FE Thread

                                      

I'm not sure... maybe the GameGear Sonic games?
My gf loves Sonic Boom! and Sonic 06 is her 2nd fave game ever



Sonic and the Black Knight

Sonic Lost World Wii U



I don't like any Sonic game that everyone else hates. I think a lot of Sonic games that a lot of people like are garbage, though. Adventure. Adventure 2. Generations. Colors. All bad. Particularly with the latter two, because it's like people compare them to the first two and think "Well... These aren't broken, unplayable messes... Must be great!" When they're really just bad games that work this time.

That being said, I still stand by the stance that Sonic Advance 2 is the best Sonic ever made. While no one really hates that game, it's definitely criminally underrated.



Around the Network

Sonic Dash.



StarOcean said:
I'm not sure... maybe the GameGear Sonic games?
My gf loves Sonic Boom! and Sonic 06 is her 2nd fave game ever

She better be a leftie as well or else it's time to dump her!

Unless she likes Samus, then we're cool.

I'm afraid to ask, but what are the current gen games she likes? Knack? :p



Gonna have to go with Sonic Heroes if only for nostalgia really. While I haven't seen as much hate for it as say 06 or Boom, I feel like it's over looked or neglected when people think back on favorite Sonic games (not that I blame them).



Sonic and the Black Knight.



Sonic and the Black Knight: Could be very tedious at times and the gameplay itself felt unpolished, but overall I liked it. Especially the levels you just run and swing around like spinning saw.

Not how others feel about this but Tail's Adventure was really really good. No one really talks about it, but I feel that that should have continued. That was a quality game

I liked Shadow the Hedgehog more than I hated it. The uber completionism was befuddling and toxic though.
Still sorta want to play Lost World, but they put me off with the color powers

 

EDIT: Also Sonic Heroes. Loved it. Know its more or less evenly divisive, but I don't get the hate for this game frankly