Quantcast
Super Mario Maker - Metacritic: 89

Forums - Nintendo Discussion - Super Mario Maker - Metacritic: 89

I'm struggling to comprehend how you review a game thats purpose is too make games... Or at least how ion earth you can give it a numerical score when the majority of the content you'd want to try doesn't exist yet.



Around the Network

84 for me, +5 from metacritic at the moment, i know some would lower the scores and i saw one already with a 70. haven't read their full review though on why it is 70.



89 with 33 reviews... Come on, 90 is so close...



Blob said:

I'm struggling to comprehend how you review a game thats purpose is too make games... Like the majority of the content you'd want to try doesn't exist yet.


You rate the creation suite for its ease of use, depth and potential. There are a load of levels that come with it as well



gabzjmm23 said:
84 for me, +5 from metacritic at the moment, i know some would lower the scores and i saw one already with a 70. haven't read their full review though on why it is 70.

It's pretty poorly written. It starts with "I don't like level editors" or something along that line. He also hasn't uploaded any levels, so he probably didn't create a lot of things. Complains about irrelevant things as "only being able to make Mario levels (it's called Mario Maker for a reason you know)" and the 9-day unlock system (just change your internal clock if it bothers you). Contradicts himself when he says you can only play as Mario to later say amiibo unlocks costumes.



Around the Network

that's pretty good so far!



nice

Mbolibombo said:
Game Reactor has released their reviews as well, I thought they were "big enough" for Metacritic but I guess they arent. Still.. here they are.

GR Sweden - 10/10
GR Germany - 10/10
GR Norway - 10/10
GR Finland - 9/10
GR Italy - 8/10


-.- damn italian countryman why did they have to give it an 8 ? the game lacks of some content, but there's already enough content in it to make endless games...



Luke888 said:
Mbolibombo said:
Game Reactor has released their reviews as well, I thought they were "big enough" for Metacritic but I guess they arent. Still.. here they are.

GR Sweden - 10/10
GR Germany - 10/10
GR Norway - 10/10
GR Finland - 9/10
GR Italy - 8/10


-.- damn italian countryman why did they have to give it an 8 ? the game lacks of some content, but there's already enough content in it to make endless games...

they hate their plumbers i guess. :D



Samus Aran said:
gabzjmm23 said:
84 for me, +5 from metacritic at the moment, i know some would lower the scores and i saw one already with a 70. haven't read their full review though on why it is 70.

It's pretty poorly written. It starts with "I don't like level editors" or something along that line. He also hasn't uploaded any levels, so he probably didn't create a lot of things. Complains about irrelevant things as "only being able to make Mario levels (it's called Mario Maker for a reason you know)" and the 9-day unlock system (just change your internal clock if it bothers you). Contradicts himself when he says you can only play as Mario to later say amiibo unlocks costumes.

thanks. we would see if that is the only 'yellow' rating that we would see in metacritic.  this type of reviews which they don't like level editors genre is already a negative journalism, so why would they give it to someone who doesn't like level editors, of course, they won't like the game to begin with.

i still think mid-80s is a fair enough rating.  i don't know the full content and couldn't find any.  but are there any information on what are the missing enemies from SMM? like the american footballer enemy in SMW?  are there any tank levels like in SMB3?



gabzjmm23 said:
Luke888 said:


-.- damn italian countryman why did they have to give it an 8 ? the game lacks of some content, but there's already enough content in it to make endless games...

they hate their plumbers i guess. :D


I mean, it's stereotypical towards us, but I don't really know how much that affected the review, I'm more of the opinion that some Fifa/Assassin's Creed player reviewed it :/