Tell me your favorite controller and I'll tell you your primary platform of choice.
Thats basically how these threads go, its not fanboyism.., its just familiarity.
My favorite controller is Xbone, but my console of choice is a Wii U.
An your right its not fanboyism, just familiarity. I've only owned one Playstation console so I guess that's why I don't really like DualShock controllers whereas I've owned every XBOX console and I think their controllers are all great.
In my case the whole "familiarity" doesn't hold true. I am 35 years old so I used the first Dual Shock YEARS before I ever used an Xbox controller and now, I prefer that over the dual shock.
There is just something easier about FPS and first person games in general with that analog placement. I think it's the left stick being higher on the controller. When it's down, my thumb has to stretch right which makes it slip off the stick time and again. I never had that happen with the Xbox controller.