Are we using canon or just anything we can pull out of our asses right now? Because some of this stuff isn't canon (ie All Star Superman).

At least us Superman supporters are using official comicbooks. The Goku side keeps bringing up fanfiction.

It might frighten him to know the fact that Superman Prime is vastly stronger than AS Superman then. I was just giving a few feats that he has accomplished in his comics, as opposed to Goku who hasn't done a fraction of what Superman is capable of.

It's not really weird actually. DBZ is horribly inconsistent in regards to a lot of character abilities and how a lot of things should work. At one point a Kamehameha doesn't do crap to Piccolo in DB, at another it completely disintegrates Cell. 

Biggest bull in the show is HOW Ki actually works or what it actually is. It's a terrible plot device that does EVERYTHING the creator wants it to and can be generated in higher quantities...by God knows what methods. 

Thing is that I doubt Toriyama considered any physics ideas while writing DB. It's all the better for it, but very strange at times as well. 

Edit: In the previous page of the manga Goku states that if he would be tied down with 10t on each limb, he wouldn't be able to move at all. So it's not about ki energy there. 

Here's Screw Attack's analysis:

http://www.screwattack.com/news/final-analysis-superman-and-goku-w-power-levels

Of course Superman will win. He was written to win every fight which makes him a terrible character. There is an actual attempt at consistency in Dragonball, and an attempt to make the characters believable, so of course he's going to lose.

Wow. That was one sick burn.

Consistency in Dragon Ball? Yeah right. They go from pushing mountains apart to struggling to life 40 tons. I mean Master Chief can lift 66 tons! That's way stronger! And Superman has lost. It's just rare.

He should know that. He was apparently a comic book reader before.

I'm actually a huge DC (and comics in general) fan--one of the biggest you'll find-- and I agree with the results. I just try to be unbiased in comparisons.  I want the picture painted clearly so there's no room to nitpick.