I don't see the word "JRPG" anywhere near DOOM, so no. Not perfection.

This game is going to be a blast for sure. Have been fixated on it since Bethesda announced it. Glad to see it is as I remember and then some.

This was meant to show off, I thought something about the AI but I'm sure this isn't really reflective of it. I imagine the AI was pretty dumbed down here in order to just show off the kills gunplay and avoid the possibility of mishaps and even death or whatever. 

Looked fucking fantastic. Though will the game always lock you in a kill animation for ever melee or chainsaw kill?

Doom 2's better :P

It was the best thing at Bethesda's conference..and the best from E3 so far.

Agreed on the first part, still think the ending of the NWC is the best from E3 so far though

The game reminded me of those police training courses where the bad guy signs just pop up out of nowhere and you have to shoot them.

Actually looks kinda cool, but I got some flashbacks to Bulletstorm, which was not all positive. This is a fine balancing act betwen over-the top action and actual challenge and at least some degree of thinking involved. Right now, it looks as if you have an arsenal of one-hit kill attacks at your disposal.
Most shooters have at least one class of cannon fodder enemies, this game appears to have only cannon fodder enemies judging by this trailer.
But, it's an early look and it has potential for sure.

The visuals and sound effects are amazing but I feel that they reverted back to the old formula here compared to the cancelled version that resembled Killzone mixed with COD. I hope it is a good game but I feel it will feature nothing significantly new. We shall see.