I'd go with Bayonetta, it is one of my favorites of this gen so far.

Depends. Would you rather be a child hero on an epic adventure? Or a busty witch with attitude caught in an acid trip?

Hope that helps! Both games are amazing, though. Just very different.

I can't really argue if Wind Waker is an option. I'm not a huge fan of Bayonetta, but it's a good game. For NSMBU, I would suggest both Super Mario 3D World and Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze over NSMBU. 3D World for Mario platforming, and Tropical Freeze for one of the best 2D platformers. Not that NSMBU is necessarily bad, but it's pretty basic: a simple platformer, that's all.

Bayonetta 2 is a must have for any Wii U owners!

WW HD definitely, if only for the lovely music and the exploring (temples aren't that great in this one, but it has other qualities to make up for that). Bayo 1 + 2 are must plays if you like hack and slash games, if you like bayo give the W101 a shot, it feels like a bayonetta game and definitely plays like one.

You can't go wrong with either Windwaker or Bayonetta.You can go very wrong with nsmbros u though.It's a pretty mediocre game that recycles a lot and brings nothing new.

All three of them :)

If you never played the original, then Zelda. Otherwise, Bayo.

All three are worth playing, though. The Luigi DLC for NSMBU is really cool, especially if you're down for more of a challenge.

They're all great choices ofcourse but I'd have to tip Wind Waker. Excellent remastering and still a joy to play now.

I wish I could wipe my memory of WW so that I could play it again for the first time.