If you asked me a few months ago, I would have told you that Halo would win, no contest. Two million is lower than I thought for the MCC though. I think Uncharted could pull it off, especially if there are a lot of players on the PS4 who never owned a PS3.

ROFl, they are 4 million undertracked bro, when will you leanr VG chartz is not accurate. ND announced today 3 games sold 21 + mill. That is 7 mill average with the last 2 selling more then the first.

A simple google shows you have no facts as usual.

Uncharted collection

Halo MCC will probably sell more because the Nathan Drake Collection doesn't have multiplayer. Because of this, a lot of day one buyers will beat it, and then flood the second hand market with their copies, even though both collections are a great deal!

So the OP takes vg chartz word for it that Halo MCC only sold 2 million, how do we know that it's not undertracked as well? You can use different sources.

WTF strawman much? Your post or mine never mentioend HALO at all. Again you said no uncharted game sold 7 million, that is WRONG, halo had nothing to do with anything.

Well , it does have a UC4 Multiplayer beta, so I doubt people will get rid of it so quickly. 

Also, people tend to hang on to collections more than to any singular game, kind of a collectible thing, I think.

Man just stop, the OP is asking which will sell more Halo or Uncharted. he used VG chartz, so I used VG chartz.

They did...

YEah and you said a blatant false post that "UC never sold more then 7 mill", I corrected you, you tried to deflect and bring up something you and I were not even discussing. You always post nonsense though so hardly surprising.