Well I mean I want QB but after reading DFs hands on I'm no longer able to make up my own mind. It looks stunning but...... After reading that, now think it looks like shit.

What would you choose if you see a new digital copy for $60 and a used one for $40? There is zero difference between the two, yet one is $20 cheaper than the other. That will eat a LOT of sales for the publisher.

If the Publishers get 10-20% cut that might convince them to allow it. Microsoft should get a cut because you're selling the game using their store, like when you sell an item through Amazon or EBay.

And even with this cut I wouldn't agree if I was a publisher.

Some AA's/AAA's are $50 on Steam at release, less than there used to be but some still are, at the very least there's no reason why those shouldn't be $50 on XBL and PSN as well.

I've said it before and I'll say it again, MS really needs to work on improving the Xbox Store and now Windows 10 store as well (the two will be merged later this year). Faster and bigger price cuts over time (no game should still be full price a year after release, they aren't at retail and they aren't on Steam, so they shouldn't be on XBL either, MS needs to work to match physical prices over time), more sales with bigger discounts (quarterly sales where most games are on sale, monthly sales where a good number of games are on sale, plus the standard weekly deals with gold stuff).

Digital reselling would be nice, but 10% is too low, not when you can usually get at least 20% reselling a physical game (often more depending on how quickly you finish the game). And they need to copy Steam's refund policy, if you buy a game and you don't like it, you should have 14 days or 2 hours of playtime (whichever comes first) to get a refund. A digital rental service would be amazing as well, something like 70% of a game's selling price to rent it for 2 weeks, 50% of a game's selling price to rent it for a week, 30% to rent it for 3 days, and 15% to rent it for 24 hours. If they worked out a deal where most of that money went to the devs, the devs would actually prefer digital rentals to phyiscal rentals because they'd get more money from digital rentals than they do from physical rentals.