After Zelda and Uncharted 4 were delayed we didn't get the holiday showdown we wanted, but not to fear as we still may get some comparative showdown!

We for some reasons seem to think Zelda U will come out holilday 2016. So with them all releasing in completely different time periods of eachother with different bonus' it can be an almost quite not really kind of close fight. 

Holiday bundle Halo 5 Vs March Uncharted 4 vs Holiday (hopefully) bundle Zelda U.

I think the install base difference will still take affect but maybe Halo releasing in the holidays and Uncharted 4 releasing in March could negate some of that.

The poll says all, vote away!

Halo 5 will sell the most first week.

Halo 5 in the US > Uncharted and Zelda globally. (first week)
Lifetime, will be more close, btu still, Halo will easy win.

I don't know man... Halo is a weakening brand. I know a ton of people that bought the 360 versions, that could simply care less about it now. It'll sell XB1s, but no where as many as you seem to think.

I think the majority of halo fans have upgraded already, and the install base is gonna be too far apart.

Halo 5 > uncharted 4 > Zelda U FW and LT.

Ditto.

What does Ditto mean?

"Used to indicate that something already said is applicable a second time."

Ka-pi96 said: Yeah, Halo 5 will sell the most. Although I still think we will get our big 3 battle next year, just with Gears on Xbox instead of Halo

Nah. By then everyone who wanted to buy an X1 will have bought it with Halo. Which means X1 will sell zero consoles starting January 2016.