By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sony Discussion - Sony should pay From Software to try their hand at a Monster Hunter clone.

Sony's made a few failures... attemps at making a popular franchise similar to Monster Hunter.  Why not get From Software to make something like say 'Demon's Hunters.'

The Souls games are amazing, but one major change that I'd like to see from the franchise is doing away with the Soul levels and having a well balanced game.  If this franchise was tobecome successful, they could create new areas, new bosses, and new weapons to add onto the existing ones much like Capcom does with Monster Hunter, slowly tweaking the balance on each game towards perfection while adding content.

Not that this game would be like Monster Hunter, just a few of the concepts.  The Souls games have new game plus modes. Edit it to be like Monster Hunter  where you can replay any area you want at any difficulty with the hub worl where you'd party up and go out on quest.  It'd certainly fix the horrible match making present in Souls games.  For people who want to attack some, they could also do it from the hub world and choose which locations they'd have preference in, allowing them to attack some from every area and not strictly the place they're standing in.  This would also fix the issue with people unable to be invaded since they've happened to kill a boss.

So what I'd like to see is a system that lets you play and practice any rank of any stage with a Demon's Souls hub and environment.  They could even have quests that make you start at 1-1 and go all the way through 1-4.  You have a time limit and if you die you respawn at the beginning with only bosses stilld efeated.  Instead of having healing items like Demon's Souls  and Bloodborne you'd use Estus Flasks or something similar.  No grinding for herbs or vials, one set amount.  Create a new magic Estus Flask, have preset bullets, and preset amount of arrows, to force these characters into playing mixed builds.  Also add a colliseum From Software.  There's been four games and you know people love the pvp, yet the pc Dark Souls is the only one with an arena.



Around the Network

Should Capcom pay the Monster Hunter team to try their hand at a Souls clone?



Souls games are no where near similar to Monster Hunter. In many, MANY ways. Honestly Sony would be wasting money paying From Software to make a Monster Hunter clone.

Plus, Sony already have numerous MH clones; Toukiden, Soul Sacrifice, God Eater, I think there is going to be a Dynasty Warriors one too I think?

From Software probably have multiple Bloodborne DLC in the works anyways, and would probably like to make another Armored Core game (when it is cheap to make).

EDIT: I re-read your original post and you seem to want an add on that allows pretty much multiplayer gauntlet or arenas in Souls games. Yes, this could work, but only as DLC. A full game based on it wouldnt work.



Australian Gamer (add me if you like)               
NNID: Maraccuda              
PS Network: Maraccuda           

 

...

Last edited by OttoniBastos - on 20 February 2023

spemanig said:
Should Capcom pay the Monster Hunter team to try their hand at a Souls clone?


No but Nintendo should get Atlus, Monolithsoft, and Capcom's MH Team to work together on one. Atlus know how to be incredibly punishing, Monolithsoft rock RPG elements like no-one's business, and Capcom's MH Team have an AWESOME sense of combat... 

 

Inkborne >>> Bloodborne



Around the Network

A mech version of Monster Hunter was an idea I actually shopped to various video game developers. From Software would be perfect for this idea.



01000110 01101111 01110010 00100000 01001001 01111001 01101111 01101100 01100001 01101000 00100001 00100000 01000110 01101111 01110010 00100000 01000101 01110100 01100101 01110010 01101110 01101001 01110100 01111001 00100001 00100000

Why would they want to do that?



 

The PS5 Exists. 


Maraccuda said:

Souls games are no where near similar to Monster Hunter. In many, MANY ways. Honestly Sony would be wasting money paying From Software to make a Monster Hunter clone.

Plus, Sony already have numerous MH clones; Toukiden, Soul Sacrifice, God Eater, I think there is going to be a Dynasty Warriors one too I think?

From Software probably have multiple Bloodborne DLC in the works anyways, and would probably like to make another Armored Core game (when it is cheap to make).

EDIT: I re-read your original post and you seem to want an add on that allows pretty much multiplayer gauntlet or arenas in Souls games. Yes, this could work, but only as DLC. A full game based on it wouldnt work.

don't forget Freedom Wars



nothing really sells like monster hunter unfortunately. The only thing they can do is ask Capcom to bring MH back to PS4 or have it multiplat. Or maybe Co develop a new spin off monster hunter game so Nintendo can still have their own exclusive MH game.

Personally speaking, I would like a Gothic MH with the monsters being giant werewolves, zombies, cyclones, vampires, Devils, mutilated breasts beasts, ogres etc.

Have it all play out like a fairy tale where you get quests from different towns calling you to slay different monsters that have been posing plaguing their community. You can buy Intel from them that would help you prepare for the fight etc.

Have different towns with different themes and where you have to work your way to the boss by fighting lesser minions.



Yes please. That should reduce the output of Souls games