'Graphics' is very closely tied to game-play and influences it greatly. It's kind of hard to separate them.

Gameplay, of course.

Gamepla. The rest are are a bonus

It should be all equally perfect balance for the most people.

Personally, i buy games just for presentation in general. Graphic(Art) = Sound = Gameplay = Story.

Nidhogg disagrees with you.

Gameplay>Story>>>Graphics.

If a game isnt fun to play why bother?

Gameplay >> Graphic > Story

Content is KING.

Oh and Gameplay I guess. Graphics tend to age like milk and Story quality is immensely subjective.

Story, gameplay then graphics.

i only care about graphic, dont care about story, sound, artstyle or gameplay, thats why i like the order