By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Sony, MS and Nintendo - Which genre do you think their games are the best in?

generic-user-1 said:
Acevil said:

Nintendo: Adventure (Zelda), Platformers (2D: Donkey Kong and 3D: Mario), RPG (Xenoblade), Strategy (Fire Emblem) , Kart Racer (Mario Kart), Brawl Fighter (Super Smash Bro).
Sony: Action (Uncharted), Action-Adventure(Last of Us), Racing (Gran Tusimo), Sports (MLB).
Microsoft: Fighter (KI), and FPS (Halo)

Microsoft was the harder one, because right now fighter genre is again on the backburner.

Yes I truly believe these games are the best at what they do.

I might remove FPS if Call of Duty was on top of its game again, or if Bioshock wasn't dead. 

there are a lot better fighter out there than KI... (streetfighter???)

and halo isnt even close to the toptier fps.    this year we will get one of the realy big boys..


Street Fighter if on top of its game (Not Street Fighter IV) is the best fighter game. However I think KI from the little I played is better than Street Fighter IV. 

I did say FPS is one of those toss ups. Right now Call of Duty has lost its edge, Battlefield is just a mess, Bioshock is dead. 

I think this all goes without saying in my opinion. I don't mind arguing it, but I just hope no one takes offense "Best" of any genre.



 

Around the Network
Acevil said:
generic-user-1 said:
Acevil said:

Nintendo: Adventure (Zelda), Platformers (2D: Donkey Kong and 3D: Mario), RPG (Xenoblade), Strategy (Fire Emblem) , Kart Racer (Mario Kart), Brawl Fighter (Super Smash Bro).
Sony: Action (Uncharted), Action-Adventure(Last of Us), Racing (Gran Tusimo), Sports (MLB).
Microsoft: Fighter (KI), and FPS (Halo)

Microsoft was the harder one, because right now fighter genre is again on the backburner.

Yes I truly believe these games are the best at what they do.

I might remove FPS if Call of Duty was on top of its game again, or if Bioshock wasn't dead. 

there are a lot better fighter out there than KI... (streetfighter???)

and halo isnt even close to the toptier fps.    this year we will get one of the realy big boys..


Street Fighter if on top of its game (Not Street Fighter IV) is the best fighter game. However I think KI from the little I played is better than Street Fighter IV. 

I did say FPS is one of those toss ups. Right now Call of Duty has lost its edge, Battlefield is just a mess, Bioshock is dead. 

I think this all goes without saying in my opinion. I don't mind arguing it, but I just hope no one takes offense "Best" of any genre.

there is no best, we have CS and arma , both realy great military fps, but you cant compare them.

this year will be the year of UT. 



The most Popular or the best?

The best:

Nintendo:
Platafformers(Mario,DK, etc)
Action Adventure (zelda)
Multiplayer "Party Games":
-Racing Game(Mario Kart)
-Fighting Game(Super Smash Bros)
-Sport Game(Mario Strikers)
-Party Game(Mario Party)

Microsoft:
FPS (Halo)
Racing Sim (Forza)

Capcom:
Fighting Game(SF)
before Survival Horror(RE 0-3, Revelations)

Naughty Dog:
now Survival Horror (TLOU)

Konami:
stealth genre (MGS)

Platinum Games:
H&S (Bayonetta 1,2)

Rockstar Games:
Sandbox(GTA)

Square Enix:
RPG (Final Fantasy Vll)


The most Popular

Platafformer: Nintendo(Mario)
FPS: Activision (COD)
Sport: EA (FIFA)
Action Adventure: Naughty Dog(Uncharted) or Nintendo(TLOZ)
RPG: Nintendo(Pokemon)
H&S: SMS/SONY (GOW)
Stealth: Ubisoft (AC)
Racing: Sim: SONY(GT), Party: Nintendo(MK)
Fighting: Capcom (SF), Party: Nintendo(SSB)
Sandbox: Rokstar (GTA)
Survival Horror: Now: Naughty Dog(TLOU) Before Capcom (RE)
Party: Nintendo(Mario Party)



DAXFM said:
The most Popular or the best?

The best:

Nintendo:
Platafformers(Mario,DK, etc)
Action Adventure (zelda)
Multiplayer "Party Games":
-Racing Game(Mario Kart)
-Fighting Game(Super Smash Bros)
-Sport Game(Mario Strikers)
-Party Game(Mario Party)

Microsoft:
FPS (Halo)
Racing Sim (Forza)

Capcom:
Fighting Game(SF)
before Survival Horror(RE 0-3, Revelations)

Naughty Dog:
now Survival Horror (TLOU)

Konami:
stealth genre (MGS)

Platinum Games:
H&S (Bayonetta 1,2)

Rockstar Games:
Sandbox(GTA)

Square Enix:
RPG (Final Fantasy Vll)


The most Popular

Platafformer: Nintendo(Mario)
FPS: Activision (COD)
Sport: EA (FIFA)
Action Adventure: Naughty Dog(Uncharted) or Nintendo(TLOZ)
RPG: Nintendo(Pokemon)
H&S: SMS/SONY (GOW)
Stealth: Ubisoft (AC)
Racing: Sim: SONY(GT), Party: Nintendo(MK)
Fighting: Capcom (SF), Party: Nintendo(SSB)
Sandbox: Rokstar (GTA)
Survival Horror: Now: Naughty Dog(TLOU) Before Capcom (RE)
Party: Nintendo(Mario Party)


this list is bad and you should feel bad... fps and halo? realy?what about arma? or UT, Quake? CS?

and forza isnt even a real racing sim...  TLOU isnt realy a horror game or about survival, its a stroy driven zombieshooter

and FF has not just gotten realy bad, ff7 was never the best jrpg and isnt even the best ff...



Nintendo - platformers (all kinds), action-adventure, life sim, RPGs
Sony - TPS, racing sim, interactive dramas (Heavy Rain, Beyond Two Souls)
Microsoft - FPS



Official Tokyo Mirage Sessions #FE Thread

                                      

Around the Network
generic-user-1 said:
Acevil said:
generic-user-1 said:

there are a lot better fighter out there than KI... (streetfighter???)

and halo isnt even close to the toptier fps.    this year we will get one of the realy big boys..


Street Fighter if on top of its game (Not Street Fighter IV) is the best fighter game. However I think KI from the little I played is better than Street Fighter IV. 

I did say FPS is one of those toss ups. Right now Call of Duty has lost its edge, Battlefield is just a mess, Bioshock is dead. 

I think this all goes without saying in my opinion. I don't mind arguing it, but I just hope no one takes offense "Best" of any genre.

there is no best, we have CS and arma , both realy great military fps, but you cant compare them.

this year will be the year of UT. 


I don't find CS to be that great of an FPS, given I don't find the half life engine to be that great. As for Arma I might give you that (The Moding community showcases what arma can really do), but I will just change it to Console FPS. 



 

Nintendo : platformers, strategy, RPG, adventure, party, (includes games with party elements such as MK and SSB)

Sony: (Cinematic) action, sims

MS: shooters



Spending warm summer days indoors   

Writing frightening verse

To a buck-toothed girl in Luxembourg

NES, SNES, N64, GC, Wii, WiiU, GB, GBC, GBA, DS, 3DS, Mega Drive, Game Gear, PS1, PS2, PSP, XBOX 360, Atari Lynx

Nintendo: 3d/2d platformers, action-adventure, racing, rpg, strategy, puzzle, casual, local-multiplayer

Microsoft: Shooters, online multiplayer

Sony: TPS



Samus Aran said:
wangjingwanjia said:


This I would go with as well. MS for shooters, Nintendo for platformers and Sony for adventure games.

But I would say that Sony is really good with both platformers and shooters as well, I would at least put them in second place for both. Nintendo in second place for adventure games.

So for all-around I think Sony would be the one with the biggest variety of genres with good or decent games. Microsoft also has a big variety but is missing out on especially platformers and adventure games. Nintendo on the other hand is missing out on shooters, especially, but also sports/racing games. They have their own such as Mario Kart etc. but lack a proper GT/Forza which Sony/MS has.

MS now that they have Minecraft and at least a timed exclusivity of Tomb Raider, and are hopefully working on Banjo 3 will fill in the gap which they currently have. Next generation Minecraft might be exclusive to the MS brand and Banjo might be re-born as an excellent series again. Tomb Raider I don't think will stay exclusive to MS permanently, but it would benefit them very much if it did.

Metroid and Zelda are also adventure games. Some of the best in the industry. Realistic racing games suck imo, Nintendo doesn't need that lol. They have F-Zero and Mario Kart. Mario Kart is the biggest racing franchise in the world. ;)

Nintendo has the biggest variety of genres by far.

I will both agree and disagree with you here. I mean, Zelda of course is the very best action-adventure game series out there, hands down. Zelda alone is what still keeps me into console gaming, if Nintendo shut down the series I might actually consider to focus only or mainly on PC gaming. That's how high I hold that series. :)

But in my opinion, even though Nintendo has Zelda and Metriod which are two great series, Sony has more series in the same genre which are also great/good games. So I think they (Sony) should win that one. But if I would focus on only the very best game, then yes Nintendo wins that genre too, with Zelda.

For racers, even though Mario Kart is a great game I believe that if Nintendo is missing something it is a proper racing sim in the lines of GT/Forza. Maybe you think they don't need it, and that's fair enough, but they do miss one. :P

And the last part I disagree with, I think that Sony has the biggest variety with good games in most genres. Nintendo I could agree has the most great games in the most genres, and absolutely the very best games in a lot of genres, but they are in less genres than Sony and even MS.



MS is good at making FPS's, Sony at action adventure games, and Nintendo at platformers, racing and fighting games.



    

NNID: FrequentFlyer54