By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - The Order 1886 reviews proves gaming journalism is a farce and a disgrace. (9 out of 10)

Gaming journalism is a complete sham. Like most news of today it has lost integrity in an effort to compete with bloggers and social media. Honest reporting has taken a backseat to sensationalized, clickbait, lowest common denominator trash. Payouts, scandals, controversy, political bias, all have turned the world into people living in a bubble or vaccum of their liking. The Order 1886 is a remarkable video game. Not just in the quality of its technical aesthetic (which is the most astonishing thing ever seen in a video game) but in its storytelling and diverse gameplay that does what's right for its story and not what's right to appeal to every gamer under the moon. Single player campaigns are the heart and soul of gaming. Always has been and always will be. Games that tell an immersive story and envelops the player in an incredible gaming experience is still a profitable sphere. And The Order will be successful. I bought it. I loved it (all 11 hours of my first play through) and so will millions of others. The gaming media won't change that. Multiplayer is an added bonus in video games. Every game doesn't have to be everything for everyone. And the outright hatred and bias this game has faced for not being Call of Duty or even Gears of War is despicable. Gears of War dreamed it had a story and universe this sophisticated and well written. Gears of Wars story and characters seem as if written by drunken frat boys who wanted to make an alien invasion game. A quintessential dude bro fiasco with over maschismoed steroid junkies as leads. The Order aspires to be more than that. An I appreciate its classy take on the genre. Sorry if you don't. But not everyone wants their gaming dumbed down.

And furthermore, I have never been a tin foil hat wearing conspiracy theorist. But GOOD LORD some of these reviews wreak of alterior motive and disingenuous bias. Take this Digital Trend review for example. There is no way in absolute hell you can in good conscience score this game a 1. The quality is just too good. It's an undeniable technical masterpiece regardless if you find its gaming shortcomings egregious or not. I didn't because I really enjoy cinematic experiences. And the gun combat is incredible when it's there. Granted their could be more in the game. It's not perfect by any stretch but a 1?! Yeah right. The fact that the guy at Digital Trends used to be editor at Xbox The Magazine is a glaring red flag. I do believe he and SOME (not all) oft hear reviewers had a clear motive when harshly damning this game. Some people fear this game can rival and surpass Gears of War. Well Iin terms of story, lore,  graphics, and  characters it eclipse it by lightyears.  Gameplay and game modes wise it admittedly hasn't but it has potential to with a sequel. Anyone who loved Uncharted, Heavy Rain, or God of War will love it. No multiplayer in those games, no new game plus, incredible experiences. Which is exactly what the Order is. An incredible gaming experience. A must have if you own a PS4.

 



Around the Network

If only MS wouldn't flood all the reviewers with their anti Sony money. Then maybe PS4 and Playstation games would actually sell well instead of always being less successful than their competitors.

Also I think FFXIII tells an immersive story with excellent polished gameplay but the majority of this forum disagrees with me which makes all of this forum and its mother a farce and a disgrace.



If you demand respect or gratitude for your volunteer work, you're doing volunteering wrong.

as much as i like to make fun of gaming journalism it sounds if i play The Order it sounds i will likely agree with them cause from what i hear this game just does so many things i hate in games

QTE fest
long unskippable cutscene's
short length (a good portion of which i hear is cutscene's)
no replay value
a lot of gameplay is actually just walking with no action happening

plus i've heard the story falls apart towards the end and the ending is really terrible





Tagged.



Around the Network

havent played the game yet to judge it. but i been disagreeing with reviewers a lot since around mid 2013.



Reviews are opinions. Your just a minority who loves this game, which is absolutely fine.



Does this account typically make troll threads. This can't possibly be a serious thread, can it?



Ah yes, Microsoft paying every single reviewer, including many independent ones, great amounts of cash to make the Order 1886 look bad. How dare they. Maybe they should have paid them to say that Ryse was good too.



                                                                                                               You're Gonna Carry That Weight.

Xbox One - PS4 - Wii U - PC

Who cares about journos anymore in 2015?

http://www.google.com/trends/explore#q=ign%2C%20gamespot%2C%20eurogamer%2C%20twitch&cmpt=q&tz=