TRAVIS!!! said:
niallyb said:
Because a lot of young male gamers are not mature enough to examine their own prejudices and take her points as an opportunity to grow. For many young gamer males - a game world is the one place where they are not impotent. Its the one environment they can exercise control over.
Its far easier for them to issue anonymous threats that they don't have to be accountable for than actually make an attempt to understand the value in what she is saying. Of course their reaction has totally validated every one of her criticisms but its far easier to attack the messanger as being somehow illegitmate than seriously examine the merits of her points.
For young male gamers who typically have no close female friends and no skills to bridge the gap - she sounds like an alien. The fundamental problem is one of self awareness.
I've seen similar insanity where devs have introduced gay characters in their games. A certain segment of gamers reject the notion of being prejudiced - by behaving in an entirely prejudiced way. They simply don't have an understanding of what prejudice means or how damaging it is to others.
|
Spot on.
So many people don't even bother to watch her videos (in which she, for example, explains how violence against women is often different from violence against men, and how misogyny in games or movies can have negative impacts in real life) and rather just believe in lies that got spread on the internet.
|
Sounds like you are the one who hasn't watched her videos. She blatantly misrepresents games, cherry picks to the nth degree and I would say that she lies at times.
Take her discussion of Hitman for instance:
What she says - In Hitman, you as the player are encouraged to murder innocent females and get perverse pleasure out of watching the ragdoll physics as you move their body around. This is proof that the game encourages the sexual repression of women and encourages violence against women
What actually happens - In 2/7ths of 1/20 missions, you have the capability to kill innocent females, as you would be able to do with any innocent male character in the game. In no way does the game encourage players to kill or even interact with these women, and in fact, it actively discourages this behaviour by inflicting rather strict point penalties if you were to kill them. The goal of the level in question is to sneak by them without being noticed, and it is even possible to go a completely different route and never encounter this situation in the first place.
Additionally, it is worth noting that there is virtually no reputable evidence that proves that actions in video games are tied to actions in real life. This was a large debate a few years back (the whole "video game violence causes real world violence") and the overall conclusion by the scientific community is that these accusation hold little to no water.