I've been watching one of my favorite LPer's just start a runthrough of Super Mario RPG and it's their first time playing it, almost too funny/frustrating to watch and deal with.

It made me think about past entries in the series and I wanted to see what everyone's favorites are.

I feel pretty confident it will be a two horse race, but please vote and indicate which games you voted for and what you might love/hate about them all!

Paper Mario TTYD.. The game is amazing in pretty much everyway possible! It's a shame the later PM games didn't live up to it, specially SS! :/

This get discussed a lot but I don't mind, I like the games.

I never played the SNES game, out of the Paper Mario's it goes:

64 > Sticker Star > Super > The Thousand Year Door

I haven't really been around too long and I hadn't seen it at any point while I was browsing.

It's always fun to discuss these fun games though :D

I've only played Super Mario RPG and TTYD, though I would really like to attempt the others.

Mario RPG is also one of my favorite games ever made though. Everything about it is just insanely fun.

The Thousand Year Door. Simply amazing.

7 to 7 for the 2 front runners.
Looks like my prediction was right so far !

Paper Mario TTYD!

Thousand Year Door, man. A decade later and I'm still waiting for a proper sequel.

TTYD is a masterpiece. If we get a Paper Mario that's in that style for the Wii U, I would cry tears of joy.