Quantcast
Would you rather Twilight Princess or Skyward Sword get the WWHD treatment?

Forums - Nintendo Discussion - Would you rather Twilight Princess or Skyward Sword get the WWHD treatment?

Tagged games:

?

Twilight Princess 266 78.24%
 
Skyward Sword 74 21.76%
 
Total:340
Talal said:

curl-6 said:

And I stand by the latter. This is a  theoretical "if you had to choose". I would rather neither be made, personally.

You would buy it though. Or else answering the question that you yourself raised would be worthless and meaningless.

I probably wouldn't buy either actually. I answered because, as I said, it's a "if you had to pick" matter.



Around the Network

Twilight Princess because it was originally designed for a controller so could easily work with the gamepad.



twilight princess.

Since Skyward sword works and looks great with dolphin.

Twilight princess doesn't look great even with dolphin, and has issues. So that one.



curl-6 said:
Talal said:

curl-6 said:

And I stand by the latter. This is a  theoretical "if you had to choose". I would rather neither be made, personally.

You would buy it though. Or else answering the question that you yourself raised would be worthless and meaningless.

I probably wouldn't buy either actually. I answered because, as I said, it's a "if you had to pick" matter.


So you create a thread asking whether you would rather get X or Y game and then answer your own question with one of the choices and in reality you wouldn't want either to be made and you wouldn't buy either. Makes a lot of sense. 

Anyway I don't want to start trouble. I was just trying to show you that your reaction to something you do not like (or care about) being remade is "for fucks sake this is ridiculous" "Developers are so creatively bankrupt" "what a waste of resources and time". But you do not react the same way to things that you actually enjoy or like, for example Bayonetta 1 on Wii U and now this theoretical scenario.



Twilight Princess for sure



Around the Network
Talal said:

So you create a thread asking whether you would rather get X or Y game and then answer your own question with one of the choices and in reality you wouldn't want either to be made and you wouldn't buy either. Makes a lot of sense. 

Anyway I don't want to start trouble. I was just trying to show you that your reaction to something you do not like (or care about) being remade is "for fucks sake this is ridiculous" "Developers are so creatively bankrupt" "what a waste of resources and time". But you do not react the same way to things that you actually enjoy or like, for example Bayonetta 1 on Wii U and now this theoretical scenario.


If I was posed the question of whether I'd rather chop my arm off or swallow a live eel, answering the latter doesn't necessarily mean I actually want to swallow an eel, it's just the preferable of the two if I had to pick.

Mario Galaxy is one of my favourite games of all time, but if Nintendo announced HD remaster tomorrow, I wouldn't buy it, and I'd be annoyed they didn't invest in new games instead.

I only forgave Bayonetta 1 cos it came for free with Bayo 2.



curl-6 said:

If I was posed the question of whether I'd rather chop my arm off or swallow a live eel, answering the latter doesn't necessarily mean I actually want to swallow an eel, it's just the preferable of the two if I had to pick.

Mario Galaxy is one of my favourite games of all time, but if Nintendo announced HD remaster tomorrow, I wouldn't buy it, and I'd be annoyed they didn't invest in new games instead.

I only forgave Bayonetta 1 cos it came for free with Bayo 2.


Those 2 questions are not similar at all. With your example it's a clear case of choose the least awful one if you were forced to choose. In this thread your question is which you would rather be remade. Besides since you wouldn't buy either why would you rather they remade TP? You're not gonna buy either anyway so your answer is worthless. No one would be forcing you to buy one of the 2 games if they were remade.

 

And no your complaints were "waste of resources and time" and "creatively bankrupt developers" so Bayonetta 1 being free doesn't explain why you forgave it.



SS since It is the better game besides it would look amazing. TP needs a lot of work to look good



    R.I.P Mr Iwata :'(


They need to remake twilight princess it was one of my favorite zeldas period and I need it to get the best treatment possible lol.



Talal said:
curl-6 said:

If I was posed the question of whether I'd rather chop my arm off or swallow a live eel, answering the latter doesn't necessarily mean I actually want to swallow an eel, it's just the preferable of the two if I had to pick.

Mario Galaxy is one of my favourite games of all time, but if Nintendo announced HD remaster tomorrow, I wouldn't buy it, and I'd be annoyed they didn't invest in new games instead.

I only forgave Bayonetta 1 cos it came for free with Bayo 2.

Those 2 questions are not similar at all. With your example it's a clear case of choose the least awful one if you were forced to choose. In this thread your question is which you would rather be remade. Besides since you wouldn't buy either why would you rather they remade TP? You're not gonna buy either anyway so your answer is worthless. No one would be forcing you to buy one of the 2 games if they were remade.

And no your complaints were "waste of resources and time" and "creatively bankrupt developers" so Bayonetta 1 being free doesn't explain why you forgave it.

I answered which I would prefer if it had to be one or the other. If you don't like my answer, that's not my problem.

If Bayonetta 1 wasn't a free pack-in, I would not have bought it. It came with Bayonetta 2 for the price of one game. I don't feel awfully compelled to complain about getting free stuff.