Maybe Red Dead Redemption.

I was really looking forward to it but found it boring as all hell

Any fighting game. There is nothing fun about overlong, pedantic button combinations.

I love the arcade game Blueprint but it is extremely frustrating and cheap. At some point in the game, you have to worry about three or four things at once. Ollie Ogre can throw a flowerpot at you while he chases Daisy as you're trying to diffuse a bomb and keep Sneaky Pete at bay. Later, Fuzzy Wuzzy can get in your way.

As for 2014 games, I couldn't enjoy The Evil Within. Terrible frame rate, ugly graphics and display, poor POV and frustrating auto-saving turned me off. Just wasn't digging it. It could have been so much better. I've got to stop buying Bethesda games. At least I only paid $14.74 for it.

COD 4 on Veteran. I think that's the hardest game I ever played. I really liked the game though.

League of Legends for me

I knew you were going to say this =P

Anyway I guess I will go Catherine and I only played on easy =(  Puzzles arent my strong suit it seems, but nothing would stop me from finishing a Persona Team game.

Any PC MOBA I've tried. I absolutely hate them and their communities.

All Fifa or PES games, I hate this genre of games xDDD

League of Legends??? =D

Uhhhh Battletoads takes the cake here....