Sorry, I don't understand. Demons souls and dark souls are horrible games, sorry.

It looks amazing, I might get it.

I'm loving the game, even after being a doubter at first. Unlike other recent games (looking at you Ubi), it also runs decently well on PC too. The only thing holding it back from game of the year is kinda bad character models and animations, the hair looks like it came from a PS2 game, lips shine waaaaay too much, and a bunch of the characters, especially the romance options, have really mediocre looking models and are very limited, compared to the Mass Effect games at least. It was a real bummer when I realized that the only straight options were human, and neither was really all that appealing (one isn't even a party member, the other gets outclassed very fast in the game).

9.5/10 from me, I love the game dearly, but I still think either Bayonetta 2 or Smash U deserve the reward more.

I disagree, you pointed out one overly picky "problem" with the story and said that made it bad...your character was accused of causing the rift, that's pretty good motivation to want to close it to prove your innocence.

Haven't even taken one on yet, took a giant (or whatever it was on) and won.

And i only just worked out what the Shards are for 27 hours in. :P

Oh man, I took on the initial dragon in the Hinterlands and it just crapped all over me. Unlike in Skyrim where the dragons are pushovers, this game actually gives them terrifying power that they deserve.

Giving it GOTY is debatable, but it still is a really good game and I give props to Bioware for how well put together it is.

You can limit the amount of potions characters take can't you? I think most are set to 2 only, but the player character might be more open. Check their tactics stuff.

I'm no going to try and take one on yet until I've done a bit more story. In DA:O and DA2 the dragons were the hardest bosses, so don't intent to do it yet. I gots times.

I have to say, after the catastrophy of the Mass Effect 3(get the good ending for dlc). I partially lost faith in Bioware and more importantly EA as they are the ones who inflicted the dlc. However I have only heard good things about this game, so if I'm not bankrupt by the end of fall, i'll probably pick it up.

Until then I can't say whether or not it deserves goty from personal experience. Contrary to that I've played SSb4 and have seen that it is the highest rated (non-remastered) game this year so my bet for goty is on that. Again huge Mass Effeect fan, and I guess in a sence Dragon age would be a fantasy (not sci-fi) Mass Effect experince. 

It's like comparing final fantasy and elder scrolls. Dark Souls and Dragon Age are not aiming for the same type of experience, dude.