I loved TP GC version. Never played the Wii port. Hate Skyward Sword. So my vote is SS worst. Don't need to explain myself why. I've done it in past SS threads.

Twilight Princess is the best. I think Wind Waker is the worst and even then it's very good.

I loved TP, but i would agree it is the weakest 3D Zelda. I hope NIntendo decides to revisit it at some point so they can make some improvements.

Worst of Zelda is still better than most other games.

I don't think it's the worst one myself. I would give that to Skwyard Sword(a great game). Skyward Sword just had too much handholding. The sword play was fun, but it kind of weighed heavy later in the game and diminished it somewhat.

I like TP as my 2nd favorite 3D Zelda. I thought everything was pretty much spot on. I really liked the wolf sections. I hardly think gimmick qualifies as it was woven into the narrative and the gameplay sections and exploration options were really well done. It wasn't just an attention getter, which is what a gimmick really is.

On another note, I would have to say gimmick is the mostly widely thrown around word in gaming. It's usually used to describe something that doesn't appeal to someone.

SS is the worst. Semi-open world, disconnected overworld, no nightime exploration, the whole sky is pretty pointless and the limited inventory and stamina system are horrible. I did really enjoy the desert sea area though and the time stones.

i agree.
but the weakest is still a 90+ game.

It's great how you moved the goalposts right away, so that I couldn't even suggest Link's Crossbow Training.

When you say TP has a darker tone, What do you mean exactly? it doesn't have a darker tone, majora's mask does. TP only have a black/green filter

2nd best 3D Zelda imo, though I've yet to play WW and didn't get the chance to finish OoT.

Worst one is SS. Having motion controls in places where it shouldn't be (swimming, flying, aiming with the motion+ instead of the pointer) is bad enough, but what really cements its dead-bottom position for me is having the least interesting world and weakest story in any 3D Zelda. Also, a really underwhemlimg final boss.

On the bright side, at least it has three of the best dungeons in any Zelda game (both Lanayru Desert dungeons and the final one).

Although it was on Wii this was built from the ground up as a GameCube game and I played it on that. For me I thought the game was brilliant and a great farewell to one of my favourite consoles.