Which still wouldn't have been optimal, but at least would've not killed someone innocent or ridiculously stupid, now, I was sure that Khan might be scum at some point, so honestly, if it came down to me, imp and khan, I would've lynched Khan instead of him, if it where up to radish, imp and me it would've been an ez decision

Also, it is funny, it hurt us very much that /everyone/ that was left at the end, was too lazy to go back and read.

And I really blame spurge for me voting him, I mean, I knew he was town, but to me he didn't do a single thing to help me defend him at any point... I mean, I think I was the one that pushed the lynch away from spurge to smeags (thankfully maybe to me misreading my rolepm, or better said, simply forgetting)

Actually we did! We redirected you to Wonk! That's how we knew spurge was lying! You couldn't have gone to Khan like he said because we sent you to Wonk, thinking you were the SK. When you flipped jester, we thought spurge was the SK because we knew he was lying and wasn't on our team so we assumed he wasn't town. Spurge is the reason we killed Conegamer. His lies actually significantly helped town. I wouldn't have gone so aggressively after him if I didn't know for a fact that he was lying. I thought there might be a second scum faction because of something Imp told us, so when I went after Khan the first day, I really thought I was finding scum, and then again with spurge. So I would have been much less suspicious if spurge hadn't lied and thus I wouldn't have voted him.

But at the same time killing me sorta screwed you over. Looking at roles; I'd say it surely would have been better to just scan as many people as possible.

Well the first night Imp said there might be another mafia team. I really thought Khan was mafia. That night, we figured the other mafia would have a way to recruit you too, so we wanted to rush it, at least until we found the serial killer. I mean think about it, if we spend a night scanning the SK, that's one less night we can control them. If you'd poisoned the first night, we wouldn't have tried for Wonk, and have gone for spurge instead, and probably would have found you by process of elimination. Ironically, it was spurge's lying that led to me doing the process of elimination wrong. That and a big assumption on my part that Clyde wasn't the Master Hand because he said "I have a day power, but I haven't used it yet," and Master Hand of course had. So we almost found you without needing Imp's role scans. Once we'd found you, we were going to use Imp as a role cop exclusively. I personally don't think it was a mistake to do it this way. It wasn't our not using the rolecop ability that led to your death, it was spurge's lying and my misinterpretation of Clyde's statement. And really it was just spurge's fault. If he hadn't lied about Smeags, we'd have just let town lynch him without our help, and scanned you, since you seemed slightly less town than Clyde. Also, if you had poisoned Night one instead of saving it, we'd never have wasted a scan on Wonk, and we'd have found you even sooner. Figures you didn't even know we were looking for you, yet Master Hand gets a notification that someone is after him. Prof, you're a bastard. But yes, killing you screwed us over somewhat, Cone. This would've been much easier if we'd found you. Honestly though, I'm glad with how it turned out. We won without your help. You were last place, Smeags was first, and we were second. I'm content with that.

There was a dead thread this whole time O.o

I can't believe I missed up what my role did. I seemed to be reality in the clear until everyone started demanding my role and then I thought it did something different to what I actually did >
Sorry again for the long periods of absence >

Hey, you won! Good job.

The game would have been easier if we had not killed you, so yeah, it would have been preferrable to not kill you at night. The mistake we made though was in misinterpreting Clyde. In retrospect it would have been possible to conclude that he was master hand but we were conserned that he was a daytime vig based on one passing comment he made. 

I know the role I had was intended by prof to be used as a scan first then recruit role, but we abandoned that path and I don't think that was a mistake. It gave us more time to try to find a SK and we got the role information we needed from claims anyway. Sure, we might have learned that Khan was just a flavor cop and it would save us some worry and we could have known we could have killed stefl and whomever he consumed at the same time, but Stefl was always immune thanks to the hammer vote. Instead, I chose to mimic the doctor since we knew the town healer was dead on Night one but town didn't and I actually had a doctor power that could be tested and proven if need be.

And of course, as Hylian says also, I don't feel like going back and second guessing a strategy that just lead to a win (that was looking pretty unlikely a couple of Days into the game none the less)

Yeah, I was kinda salty when you claimed you are "not as much a doctor" as I thought... there was this one post where you said you were basically a psychiatrist.

Honestly, the biggest problem we had was letting trough another tracker/watcher role with what we had given.