SETTLE IT IN SMASH!

The arena has opened up and Master Hand has chosen the combatants for the day!
The following power has been used:
Settle it in Smash
For the remainder of the day, only these 4 players may be voted for, and only one can be sent home.

1 impertinence
2 Astrogamer
3 Spurgeonryan
4 Wonktonodi

The vote count has been reset. Any votes on players other than these 4 have been discarded.

Ready?

GOOOOO!~

The only one that went to Khan that night, that I know of, was Stefl. Why would a redirector redirect you to stefl when at that point they didn't know your power or stefl's?

And your "partial falsehood" just caused confusion, and I don't see how you could have thought it would do anything but that. Saying you were roleblocked when someone had protected you from roleblocking? And the only person that targeted you was a redirector, not a roleblocker?

But I could believe that maybe Yoshiya randomly targeted you and then stefl, and I could believe that maybe in your twisted mind that first admitted lie was supposed to help us, but tell me, how is it that you didn't see Khan go anywhere when he obviously did? He went to Yoshiya! The only way I can think of is if stefl is lying about being a lightning rod and Yoshiya successfully redirected you to a passive role. In fact, I can confirm you didn't track Khan, so if you did track that night, you were manipulated. Which is impossible unless stefl wasn't really protecting you. Khan clearly investigated Yoshiya, so you shouldn't be suspecting him.

But then the question is, why would stefl lie about protecting you? It doesn't make sense.

Damn prof moved fast today.

My guess from all of these now is that they have had two scum and two town: which we knew from the first round which had me, padib, spurge, and whiteeagle: two town, a scum, and a guy who is all but. More recent one left us to choose between Yoshiya and Spurge.

So it is possible that our second candidate is in the list here.

In terms of voting patterns, however, it really only comes down to spurge, unless one of the others did throw their scum buddy under the bus at some point.

Of those who remain alive, only Hylian has never voted for scum, until today and his vote on spurge.

In Day 3 when spurge was throwing accusations everywhere, did he ever once accuse Yoshiya?

And i know how my post sounds, hylian. I'm not accusing you, but just making an observation, the redirector + your voting record up till now created a possibility.

I agree, but I'm wondering what your thoughts are on how this can all be explained then? Khan found Yoshiya, so we know he went somewhere Night 2, yet spurge thinks he didn't go anywhere. But the redirector targeted spurge, but was supposedly blocked by stefl, so how could spurge have been redirected, or manipulated at all for that matter?

As much as I have doubts of imp and hylian. I'm trying to think of a scenario where spurge is telling the truth and they are lying.

Spurge says he saw imp target himself. If imp were a busdriver spurge should have seen another player targeted. If hylian were the driver, who made Cone go missing?

Do we think there are 3 scum left? Or hylian can target that many people at once? That seems a little crazy.

So I don't see both imp and hylian being scum on the same team without a 3 out there. That would leave only hylian the possibility, he says what imp did and imp confirms, while not fully clearing him, if he can't he's busted.

If khan is scum, hylian should have seen something when khan scanned him night one. He also says he saw him as well as imp lastNight so they could both be on a scum team. Yes that would mean that khan threw yoshiya under the bus yesteDay, though it would also mean that day one was between scum and another scum?

I'm missing something. a role, an action, a player. Something isn't adding up. After spurge we have suspects if he is town, but what is the plan if he's scum?

Radish got confirmed by the pm mistake
Stefl, also somewhat confimred by the pm mistake since if spurge shouldn't have had it, stefl is telling the truth of his abilities (unless there is some sinister ability that would stop the pm. He also figured out yoshiya targeted spurge and caught him in a lie, about being blocked and doing nothing.
khan, has scanned 3 so far, one confimred scum and one potential today, spurge flips scum, then he's going to be in for the long game taking out so many scum buddies.
clyde is an unknown
astro has is claim, while I don't like that he didn't say what princess and he's not done much scum hunting, I do know he did nothing last night, so the kill wasn't him.
hylian, I don't like that he asked to be scanned night one when there was at least a redirector out there. I also don't like how strongly he is pushing spurge while dismissing that fact, however if he can confirm imps role, that will reduce my doubt a bit
imp I've covered some options above

bah, had left the window open and didn't finish that post for like an hour. reading what I missed.

spurge has been in all 3, anyone think that's just a coincidence?