By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Mafia Round 70 - Smash Brothers - Wahahaha! Wario Wins! (And Mafia Too I Guess...)

Khan scanned yoshiya got the battle board
Hylian targeted Khan and saw no other abilities target Khan
Nickles is a double voter/ he can take away a person's vote



Around the Network

Edit balance board



spurgeonryan said:
Could you just answer this one last question for me wonk. Then things will be clearer for you.


I had to mock you at least once first because it has been said so many times that to miss it all is so ridiculous it just screams me please



Screams lynch me please

So how many different claims have you made about last night now?



so many things to reply to.
Spurge first off, get this first. Every player has a role this game. That would mean all townies and all scum. there are no vanilla players. So a whole lot of redirection can happen at night.
Next, you didn't come out saying clearly at first that you got the PM from radish when you should have (the fact you shouldn't have received it is another matter)
When you start out saying that you are blocked, you might think you are throwing scum off in a effort to catch them, all you did was waste time for trying to figure out how the claimed night roles really went do and who is lying scum.

you aren't prof, his lies are often to catch scum and get him to survive the night, yours tend to get you lynched and leave the scum laughing.

you are right results matter, and your lie and now might make it a little harder to get the correct one.

Astro says we would only lose a day if we lynch him. so no need to protect though a cop scan might be a good idea.



Around the Network

sometimes I think there is a scum role that is holding back the votals, and night countdown :(



AstroGamer said:

It's worded a bit weird but I think it's from lynching. 

I find it interesting Clyde claimed a day power,  wonder what his power is.


I'm not going to use it yet. I don't do things until I'm sure I know what I'm doing. 



ok back to the find the lies in the night action claims.

spurge sees khan do nothing.
Khan says he went to yoshiya
Hylian sees no actions on Khan

very simple contradictions there, If spurge is telling the truth, both of them are lying.

Yoshiya, Radish and stefl all targeted spurge.

Radishes message goes through by mistake, he's pretty much confirmed at this point, FOS those who still suspect him
Stefl sees that Yoshiya targeted Spurge, I think he said later he got the message form Radish again though I will need to confirm

Yoshiya says bus driver but implies a redirect role, where he takes one player and changes who they target to someone else. If that is what he is saying than he is lying or the two redirects are in an odd contradiction. Since what happens with stelfs redirects? In my opinion it would make most sense that the redirets take place first, since other actions are determined after. Stefl gets all the targets that hit spurge, Yoshia moves Stefl to Astro instead of Spurge, every other player that targets spurge would go through. but if that was the case, the PM wouldn't have been a mistake.
While if Yoshiya is the bus driver role like he says, yoshiya swapped stefl and astro instead of spurge and astro, so stefl gets all the roles that would have hit spurge and gets the PM, now if in theory the bus took place first and stefl instead got all of the targets on Astro, he'd still get the PM since radish would have been moved to astro and then to stefl.

The problem with Yoshia being a driver and not a redirector is why would he do what he did as town? anyone investigating one would have gotten results on the other. In fact as I have said the only good use for a town busdriver is to have swapped the person he though would be killed the most with the person who wouldn't be.

If Yoshiya flips scum and Spurge town, astro is very likely to be scum, with very strong doubts on Hylian and Khan. with Yoshiya and the others trying to get a mislynch (though that many scum trying for one mislynch that could bite them back seems crazy. If Yoshiya is scum and spurge scum, Astro and khan are probably town, Hylian still slightly suspect and likely needing to be rescanned or tested.
If Yoshiya is town, then khan is more suspect.



spurgeonryan said:
I was not blocked. khan did not go anywhere.

I just wanted to see where that got us.

Am I right khan?

hmmm..?

Interesting that you are the cop or whatever you are, yet you went nowhere.

Because i have units. Marth, Fire Emblem, remember?

I'm not saying i suspect radishhead, just that we should keep track of who is defending whom or embracing which position, beyond how they vote (or neglect to vote). That combined with the data we have could just about wrap the whole thing up, after we flip our lynch target tonight.



Monster Hunter: pissing me off since 2010.

It shouldn't really matter, a tracker doesn't fallow someone, they explicitly see who that person targets. Shouldn't matter that khan has units, that's just flavor that has to do with his ability. A tracker gets no info about the ability used, but they always see who that player targets if anyone.



http://www.youtube.com/v/AoOOpLpcF28 http://www.youtube.com/v/CphFZGH5030

All Hail the Jester King. The King is back, and I am still a dirty girl prof ;)