By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Nintendo Discussion - Putting Sales aside - Do you consider the 3DS a better handheld than the DS was?

 

Which have you enjoyed more?

3DS 193 66.32%
 
DS 68 23.37%
 
See results 29 9.97%
 
Total:290

3DS by far.
DS was good, but 3DS has much more games that I enjoy!



If you're interested in Nintendo content and understand german, maybe you want to take a look at my youtube channel! :)

https://www.youtube.com/user/RealGamingExpert

Around the Network

Both handhelds are great, but I think I prefer the 3DS just a tad bit more!



                
       ---Member of the official Squeezol Fanclub---

It's basically the same... Just with 3D... which I never use...

Hardware aside, they are still pretty equal to me. But both don't even come close to the glorious GBA. :]



Official member of VGC's Nintendo family, approved by the one and only RolStoppable. I feel honored.

Ds was freezone, 3ds is not.

Nuffsaid.

And even for the games, ds is way better than 3ds.



Mnementh said:
I personally feel that the 3DS is the best console of all time, but let it check. No question, DS was a great console too.

DS vs. 3DS
Etrian Odyssey (EO2 and 3 didn't made it to europe) vs. EO4 + EO:Millenium Girl -> 3DS wins
Radiant Historia vs. nothing like that -> DS wins
nothing I'm aware of vs. SMT: Soul Hackers, SMT Devil Survivor -> 3DS wins
Zelda Phantom Hourglass and Spirit Tracks vs. Zelda OoT3D and LBW -> 3DS wins
Another Code, Hotel Dusk and Last window vs. sadly nothing -> DS wins clearly
Pokemon BW 1+2 vs. Pokemon XY -> tie
nothing vs. Bravely Default -> 3DS wins
nothing alike vs. Kid Icarus Uprising -> 3DS wins clearly
nothing I' aware of vs. Fire Emblem Awakening -> 3DS wins clearly
999 vs. Virtues Last Reward -> tie
nothing comparable vs. Resident Evil Revelations -> 3DS wins clearly
nothing vs. Monster Hunter -> 3DS
nothing vs. Project X Zone -> 3DS
Locks Quest vs. nothing -> DS
nothing vs. Luigis Mansion -> 3DS
Lost Magic vs. nothing -> DS
nothing vs. Dillon's Rolling Western 1+2 -> 3DS
nothing vs. Denpa Men 1-3 -> 3DS
nothing vs. Pullblox/Fallblox -> 3DS
nothing vs. Sakura Samurai and Steamworld Dig -> 3DS
better battery life vs. Streetpass, DLC and Virtual Console -> 3DS

15 wins for 3DS, 4 wins for DS, 2 ties. 3DS beats DS by a big margin. And that doesn't even take into account, that I can play all DS-games on my 3DS. And 3DS still gets more games, MH4 and Codename STEAM are coming at least.

I probably forgot one thing or another. Still 3DS has such a good lead, this will not change anything.

Ds is freezone, so you could get your EO2 and EO3 (the best one) on VG+ or any import site without any problem. That's what i did. -> Ds win

Devil survivor and devil survivor 2 are on Ds + Shin megami tensei : strange journey.

Pokemon black white (and white black 2) were way better than X/Y.

FF 4 heroes of light is better than bravery default (for me). Same for 999 who is better than last reward.

 

And i don't even talk about the rpg, my favorite genre, with many games you forgot on ds, such as :

7th dragon/ 2 fire emblem/disgaea/DQIX/ffTacticsA2+FF12 RW/Golden sun 3/Infinite space/Knights in the nigthmare/Lufia/Luminous Arc 1+2(+3)/Lunar knight/magical starsign/Mario and luigi :bowser story/Rune factory 2+3/TWEWY/Valkyria profile Covenant...

 

Ds is far better than 3ds, it's obvious. Maybe the 3ds will be closer to the ds near the end of her life, but for now...



Around the Network

Nah, not even close



 

"We hold these truths to be self-evident - all men and women created by the, go-you know.. you know the thing!" - Joe Biden

I think it's close. 3DS has better Mario/Zelda games ... Link Between Worlds + OoT 3D > DS Zeldas, Mario 3D Land being a new Mario game is better than a port of Mario 64 DS (even though that's a great game), and NSMB2 > NSMB.

Third party wise the 3DS started strong but has started to fizzle a bit now. But it still has Monster Hunter, had Resident Evil, Street Fighter, etc.

But for me the 3DS needs an Advance Wars 3D before I can put it above my DS.



Namiirei said:
Mnementh said:
I personally feel that the 3DS is the best console of all time, but let it check. No question, DS was a great console too.

DS vs. 3DS
Etrian Odyssey (EO2 and 3 didn't made it to europe) vs. EO4 + EO:Millenium Girl -> 3DS wins
Radiant Historia vs. nothing like that -> DS wins
nothing I'm aware of vs. SMT: Soul Hackers, SMT Devil Survivor -> 3DS wins
Zelda Phantom Hourglass and Spirit Tracks vs. Zelda OoT3D and LBW -> 3DS wins
Another Code, Hotel Dusk and Last window vs. sadly nothing -> DS wins clearly
Pokemon BW 1+2 vs. Pokemon XY -> tie
nothing vs. Bravely Default -> 3DS wins
nothing alike vs. Kid Icarus Uprising -> 3DS wins clearly
nothing I' aware of vs. Fire Emblem Awakening -> 3DS wins clearly
999 vs. Virtues Last Reward -> tie
nothing comparable vs. Resident Evil Revelations -> 3DS wins clearly
nothing vs. Monster Hunter -> 3DS
nothing vs. Project X Zone -> 3DS
Locks Quest vs. nothing -> DS
nothing vs. Luigis Mansion -> 3DS
Lost Magic vs. nothing -> DS
nothing vs. Dillon's Rolling Western 1+2 -> 3DS
nothing vs. Denpa Men 1-3 -> 3DS
nothing vs. Pullblox/Fallblox -> 3DS
nothing vs. Sakura Samurai and Steamworld Dig -> 3DS
better battery life vs. Streetpass, DLC and Virtual Console -> 3DS

15 wins for 3DS, 4 wins for DS, 2 ties. 3DS beats DS by a big margin. And that doesn't even take into account, that I can play all DS-games on my 3DS. And 3DS still gets more games, MH4 and Codename STEAM are coming at least.

I probably forgot one thing or another. Still 3DS has such a good lead, this will not change anything.

Ds is freezone, so you could get your EO2 and EO3 (the best one) on VG+ or any import site without any problem. That's what i did. -> Ds win

Devil survivor and devil survivor 2 are on Ds + Shin megami tensei : strange journey.

Pokemon black white (and white black 2) were way better than X/Y.

FF 4 heroes of light is better than bravery default (for me). Same for 999 who is better than last reward.

 

And i don't even talk about the rpg, my favorite genre, with many games you forgot on ds, such as :

7th dragon/ 2 fire emblem/disgaea/DQIX/ffTacticsA2+FF12 RW/Golden sun 3/Infinite space/Knights in the nigthmare/Lufia/Luminous Arc 1+2(+3)/Lunar knight/magical starsign/Mario and luigi :bowser story/Rune factory 2+3/TWEWY/Valkyria profile Covenant...

 

Ds is far better than 3ds, it's obvious. Maybe the 3ds will be closer to the ds near the end of her life, but for now...

I may get EO2+3 later, but currently I wait if they get remakes for 3DS, that I would prefer. You're right, currently DS will win in this area if you are willing to import.

Well, I may get Devil Survivor then. Hmm, if I do this, the DS might win in this area, until SMT IV and Persona Q hit europe, then it will be tied.

For me Pokemon XY is better than BW. The artstyle works for me and think outside it's all perfect, I'm not a fan of the camera in Luminouse City. Also Online works on the 3DS way better than on the DS, so these functions are improved a lot in XY. And that is important for an Pokemon. And lastly Pokemon Bank also adds value.

I already decided that I will get heroes of light. I will see how that works for me. Of the RPGs: I should look for the Fire Emblems, this is a series I really like. Also I might get TWEWY and Golden Sun. Still, the 3DS has also lots of good RPGs. For Bowser Story for instance you have Dream Team on the 3DS.

Even if I give DS in a few areas the win with such changes, the 3DS still leads by far. And you have to remember: it is all subjective. For you some games may have a different pririority than for me, so for you the DS might be better. This consideration above is only for me.

The only thing that I really really miss on 3DS are thre CING-games like Another Code, Hotel Dusk, Last Window. That is an area the 3DS is lacking.



3DS-FC: 4511-1768-7903 (Mii-Name: Mnementh), Nintendo-Network-ID: Mnementh, Switch: SW-7706-3819-9381 (Mnementh)

my greatest games: 2017, 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023

10 years greatest game event!

bets: [peak year] [+], [1], [2], [3], [4]

3DS is far greater then the DS but still DS has a potential this day.



Hero and Heroine Trainers Club Member.

Library wise - DS
Hardware and feature wise - 3DS

So I will have to say DS is the console I enjoyed more.



Australian Gamer (add me if you like)               
NNID: Maraccuda              
PS Network: Maraccuda