Quantcast
Starcraft Mafia - Game Thread - Concluded

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Starcraft Mafia - Game Thread - Concluded

Keep em coming. I like your answers so far.
eric would you care to answer my question please?



Around the Network

Padib, are you super busy?
I really wanted to finish that conversation we were having but it appears you grew disinterested.



theprof00 said:
QUESTION FOR ALL TOWNIES:

Using the assumption that Mafia have scans just like we do:
Do you think Spurge lied when he said Radishhead's scan was hazy?


yes, he lied. ryan was scum to me after a few posts. I think ryan tried to make radish the better option to lynch, because we know now his was scum, so maybe he tried to protect his group



Click HERE and be happy 

(6) impertinence - theprof00, Wonktonodi, radishhead, TruckOSaurus, Carl2291, EricFabian L-1
(2) padib - ConeGamer, padib

(4) Not Voting - impertinence, Mr Khan, WhiteEaglePL, Wright

With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Day 4 will last until a lynch occurs.  There is no deadline.

Please PM Smeags or myself if there's an issue with the vote count.



We're one lynch away from finishing the day.

I don't know. I'm honestly nervous. What if we're wrong about impertinence? What if we missed something?



Around the Network
Wright said:

We're one lynch away from finishing the day.

I don't know. I'm honestly nervous. What if we're wrong about impertinence? What if we missed something?


then we hope some night role can save us from a fiery doom.

if it's not him. the next biggest suspect is you. Then therer is Radish Khan and white.



theprof00 said:
If you don't care to be lynched, why are you making such a big deal of refuting my case against you.
Sure, it's not a great case. Granted.
But if you were resigned to just solving this and figuring out who the real nuker is, I honestly don't get the point of arguing with me.

Just an observation.


The only thing I can hope to prove is that I am not the nuke, that is the only 100% certain information I have. I have tried to convince town that I am not, but I am not an idiot, I can see why people find me most likely. The thing is, it's a mistake and a waste of a lynch. I know it but no one else knows yet. So, that is why I am calling your read out for what it is, a onesided confirmation bias exersise that has done nothing but push town to within one vote of a mislynch.

I've brought up the obvious flaws with your case, but there are more, no one cares to re-read it. People are confused and hoping for the best clinging to your push. That is fine, but town deserves a real read then to make a good deciscion rather than what they have been served.

Points that town need to consider about my lynch that you didn't find worth even mentioning in your herculean effort of re-reading me:

Yesterday when Wright asked if he could quote his PM I was the first to tell him no. How does that fit with the read you presented? If I am a ghost who's been working for days to get wright mis-lynched, why would I even be a part of that whole discussion around his scans and results?

Same day, when you were parading your gun around, I pushed for prolonging the day to give us more time to find the nuke. Why would I do that when you were close to rushing the day killing someone other than me?

This on top of a whole lot of other issues that doesn't make any sense for me to do as the nuke. To be honest, I am getting real tired of trying to show of completely unreasonable it would be for me to be the nuke. The case is hyperflimsy and only makes sense if you ignore all sorts of counter examples.



Wonktonodi said:
Wright said:

We're one lynch away from finishing the day.

I don't know. I'm honestly nervous. What if we're wrong about impertinence? What if we missed something?


then we hope some night role can save us from a fiery doom.

if it's not him. the next biggest suspect is you. Then therer is Radish Khan and white.

This is what I am worried about. Town thinks Wright is next in line, but they only have one night kill probably, perhaps scum comes to their senses and kill Radish and padib kills wright as he has promised over and over, and town most likely survives (unless Khan or Wright has played everyone). My concern is that scum has failed to kill anything and hasn't proved very helpful in finding the nuke so far, we don't even know if all scum will die in the nuke so hitching our hopes to them doing something useful seems pretty risky.

Anyway, I am not afraid to die. When I get killed I will have served my purpose, which is to take a bullet for town when needed.



impertinence said:
Wonktonodi said:
Wright said:

We're one lynch away from finishing the day.

I don't know. I'm honestly nervous. What if we're wrong about impertinence? What if we missed something?


then we hope some night role can save us from a fiery doom.

if it's not him. the next biggest suspect is you. Then therer is Radish Khan and white.

This is what I am worried about. Town thinks Wright is next in line, but they only have one night kill probably, perhaps scum comes to their senses and kill Radish and padib kills wright as he has promised over and over, and town most likely survives (unless Khan or Wright has played everyone). My concern is that scum has failed to kill anything and hasn't proved very helpful in finding the nuke so far, we don't even know if all scum will die in the nuke so hitching our hopes to them doing something useful seems pretty risky.

Anyway, I am not afraid to die. When I get killed I will have served my purpose, which is to take a bullet for town when needed.

He's next because he's got a claim against him, by a player who can also attack at night.

If it turns out to be radish, then WOW gave him the game with the safe claim and time limit. If khan or white, similar.

please just get on with it



Busy today, just dropping in to say I'm reading. But seriously? You're gonna leave imp one vote away? All padib would need to do is change his vote!



 

Here lies the dearly departed Nintendomination Thread.