Galaxy 3

I'd say a remake of Sunshine is more important. Played it a few weeks ago, and to say the least... It hasn't aged so well. At least not as well as most Nintendo titles from that period. The camera control is horrible, the controls in itself should be tweaked and perfected more, and everything looks more jagged than many other GC games.

But underneath these aging-issues there lies a real fun game. I'd like to see it not dying slowly like it does now.

Would I rather have a sequel to the best 3D Mario game or the worst 3D Mario game? This isn't a tough question, Super Mario Galaxy 3 of course.

I wasn't the biggest Sunshine fan and Mario Galaxy 1 is my favorite game of all time! With that said, I would rather have a sequel to Sunshine that cuts the bullshit of the original!

I actually consider Sunshine to be the most poorly made Nintendo game I've ever played...
I'll take Galaxy 3...
However, if they were to remake Sunshine, and have it do justice to every other 3D Mario, that would be grand...
Improve the controls and the camera, add some new worlds, and take out those awful blue coins...

Mario Galaxy 3! lol how is this even a question?

Galaxy 3.

Sunshine = garbage.

Galaxy 3.

Ohhh, this is hard. Both games would look amazing on the Wii U.. I can't choose..

I loved both, but I'd prefer Galaxy 3 mainly because the WiiU lacks the analog triggers :/