The reason this game get my panties in a bunch is just because I think it was terrible ploy to sell a mediocre game -_-; Of course people will like it, I can honestly see 4 million people buying it just because it has the names Mario, Sonic and Olympics :/ I HATE this game because it took two icons out of their respective ventures and stuck them in a game that could potentially be considered a cash-in.
Put it this way, I love Kratos, I love Snake, would I play Kratos and Snakes day at Nascar? F#$!@@#$@#!$@#$ NO!!!! 3 popular things, one horrid premise of a game.
I always imagined Mario and Sonics first adventure being somewhere along the lines of a cross-dimensional gap, and starting out with a very confused Mario or Sonic. I pictured Mario wondering WTF happened when he got hit by a bullet bill and rings spewed from his body, I imagined Sonic freaking out when he touched a mushroom and got enormous! I pictured Mario walking up to a massive loop-de-loop with that perplexed look on his face. Something that could have been comedic, adventurous, classic beyond any level ever experienced in a game before, but instead we got another Mini-game game >
And the other thing that really cooks the goose is that even though the game got mediocre reviews, people keep telling me around here to give it a chance!!! "Oh it's actually fun if you play" "oh give it a break it's good" "blah blah", but when other "mediocre games" *cough cough LAIR cough* come out, people who defend it get sacrificed to our VGC Alter :P and get told repeatedly to just stop trying to justify a shitty game, move on it sucks, get over it Lair blows, insert random comment, etc etc. I just don't get the double standard on something that should have much higher/stricter criteria.