Fun little fight. Just one of them will ooze with blood and guts, also do explain why :)

I say Ellie because she's in control of herself enough not to be possessed by Eiden (is that how you spell it?)

Granted, Jodie holmes is a badass martial artist, and isn't too bad at gunplay. Plus she has the advantage of eiden to scope out Ellie if she's hiding. She's also been in the military.

Stealth is Ellie's advantage, and the situation she's been in means she makes "every bullet count", so no spraying of ammo. Plus she has a knife and a bow, and if she can divert aiden by staying silent, she can snipe or bow Jodie's head off.

But I wander, if Jodie Holmes dies, does Aiden go away too, or can he still move around (if he can he wont be able to go too far since he is tethered to jodie)

Jodie would easily win...like you said, she is highly trained and she basically has super powers. No contest.

Jodie. Ellie doesn't even have stealth since the ghost eliminates that.

Buuuut, how much of an advantage is that if Eiden can't take control of her/possess her, presumably.

Jodie knows where Ellie is, and Ellie can kinda listen out for Jodie, so that kinda equals out.

Plus, Eiden is a naked dude, so he may fall for Ellie, ahha.

Ellie jumps out and kills Jodie, BAM!

A trained martial artist with military grade gunmanship against a little girl.

And now go make an interesting vs thread.

Also I clicked wrong because the poll options are the opposite of the thread title.

Yeah but Jodie is emotionally challenged and kinda mental, just kind of. Plus Eiden can be a douche at times.

Ellie is headstrong, and works better under pressure.

It can fuck up her gun or something. Let's not act like Eiden is some helpless spirit with no potencial to completely wreck Ellie on his own.

Close quarters/Hand to hand , Jodie would kick Ellie's ass.
From distance, Ellie has the upper hand ( as long as Eiden isn't around).

This feels like those old Superman vs Batman debates...everybody knows Superman would win easily, but people still sometimes pick Batman just because he is cooler.

goddamit