Conegamer said:
kirby007 said: Might be better to remove them, istead of having them half implemented |
I could agree with this. Best to not have them than to leave it unfinished.
Same with the points system as well. They're there for no real purpose after all
|
I disagree. As far as I'm concerned, they're a measure of how active and respected you are on the site that goes beyond the post count. Sure, a user has 50,000 posts, but if they got that by posting 50 times a day, hardly contributing anything each time, never making a thread, never making friends, never posting on user walls, just commenting in each thread, they'd only end up with 150,000 points. Meanwhile you've got users like spurge who have about 45,000 posts and over 500,000 points, because he's contributed to the site and done more with it. Salnax has about 6000 posts, which would be 18,000 points, yet he has twice as many points as that, because he makes incredible threads that people comment on all the time, and he has a ton of badges to show for it too. Sure, you might say making quality threads, sticking around for years, and being a friendly contributor to the community would get you respect without needing an arbitrary number or arbitrary icons underneath your avatar to back it up, but not for noobs. Having the points and badges there establishes a pecking order, so that when new people come in, they can get a better idea of who's who. A noob could easily come in to a site without points and badges and think a user with a few thousand posts over several years was nothing but a nobody lurker, while that same noob, seeing that same user having hundreds of thousands of points and tons of shiny badges, would know that the guy really had been around, and must have done something to earn it all, and might show the user more respect.
That said, the point system doesn't have to be the way it is. It could be designed better to indicate the respect a user has. For example, I've seen some sites use a system where you can give a user upvotes or downvotes when they contribute posts, threads, etc., so that their points stat reflected not how long they'd been around or how many things they'd done, but actually directly measured how much respect the user had inspired in other users. Perfect example: Reddit, with it's karma.
But also, ask yourself this: Why did gamers back in the day, and even today sometimes, try to score points in a video game? Why do gamers like achievements, trophies, and gamerscore? For the respect, that's certainly part of it, but also because it's kinda fun!