If you could only choose one or the other, would you rather a game run at 60fps or have it run at 1080p?

Personally, I choose performance.

60 fps baby.

1080p first. 60fps is useless if you can't spot where projectiles are coming from.

Depends on the game... For example, if a game has a pair of nice ballons then I need 1080p to see all the details in those curves but if its just bricks then 60 fps is fine

Performance. No one wants to play a pretty slideshow

Lol 1080p and 60fps are both perfomance.

Graphics are textures, polygons, effects, etc.

This. Same with the-pi-guy's. I voted for 60fps though, since I would prefer that for most genres.

Depends on the genre.
60 fps for Hack 'n Slash, Racing, First person shooters, Fighting, Platformers.
1080p for the rest.

Depends on the genre, but generally I would take the frames.

60 fps for shooters.

1080p, 30 fps is fine with me for everything else