Forums - Gaming Discussion - New Series of Votes: The Great JRPG's of All Time!

Tagged games:

The JRPG is one of gaming's most popular and well-known genres, with some of the biggest names in the industry. From Final Fantasy, Pokemon, Dragon Quest, Shin Megami Tensei, Monster Hunter, and Fire Emblem to Kingdom Hearts, Chrono, Xeno, Persona, Mario, Golden Sun, Souls, and Tales, this broad genre contains many of the biggest and best games ever created.

So naturally, I decided that now was a good time to vote for THE BEST JRPG IN THE HISTORY OF EVER!!!!!! With six exclamation points.

Then I realized something.

There are a lot of JRPG's.

Seriously! Although the exact definition is up in the air, if you define "JRPG" as a game with RPG characteristics made in Japan, you end up with about a thousand games to take into consideration. There's no way a single vote can cover all of that territory. According to the website GiantBomb, there are nearly 4,000 RPG games. Even if only less than half of these are Japanese, that's still well over a thousand games to consider.

That's why I decided to break this vote into sections.

 

There will be ten categories in this "Best JRPG Ever" competition. Five of them will be based roughly on when the game was released.

  • Origins - JRPG's from the dawn of video gaming through the end of the 3rd generation. Includes the NES.
  • Evolution - JRPG's in the 4th generration. Includes the SNES, Genesis, and Game Boy.
  • Prominence - JRPG's in the 5th generation. Includes the PlayStation, Saturn, N64, and Game Boy Color.
  • Maturation - JRPG's in the 6th Generation. Includes the PS2, Dreamcast, GameCube, Xbox, and Game Boy Advance.
  • Modern - JRPG's in the 7th and 8th generations. Includes pretty much every system releasedthis past decade.

 

Five will be about a game's special characteristics. Vote for games in these five special categories.

  • Story - Including Plot, theming, characters, etc.
  • Design - Which games had the best overall design and world, from traversing the Earth to the nitty gritty puzzles.
  • Gameplay - The meat and bones of the game. Which ones do it best?
  • Presentation - Including Graphics, Art Style, Music, etc.
  • Influence - Including Innovation, trend setting, new ideas and mechanics, etc.
  • Multiplayer - Which JRPG's did justice for this often overlooked aspect of the genre?

 

I'll be making one thread for each of these ten categories, and they will all link to this page. Voters can pick up to five games per category, ranked from #1 to #5.

 

Finally, after all eleven categories have been voted on, I'll pick the top three games voted for in each of the first five categories. At this point, I'll hold one more final vote, asking people to vote on their favorite five of just these 30 (or less) games.

The goal of holding such an elaborate election is to go beyond a simple "ENTER_TITLE_HERE IS THE BEST JRPG EVER" conclusion. I want to use this series of votes as an oppurtunity to chronicle the vast and fascinating history of the JRPG genre. Even when voting is done, expect a lot of interesting talking to be derived from this data.

 

F.A.Q.

Q. Which games can I vote for?

A. Almost any game that can at least partially be considered an RPG AND is made in Japan (OR is made in the Japanese style, like some Western console RPG's) is eligible for voting. However, I will NOT accept games released during or after the contest. This means that if a game is first released after January 19, 2014, it is not eligible! That said, a game only has to be released in one area to be eligible. This means that technically, Monster Hunter 4 can be voted for, though I strongly discourage people from voting on games they haven't extensively played.

Q. Do I have to vote on every category?

A. No. If you feel less than confident about one or more categories, you should probably not vote for it. It doesn't really matter. There will be at least 11 votes for this series, and even participating in a single one is greatly appreciated.

Q.Can I just vote for everything now?

A. For the first ten rounds, yes. You can vote for all of them on this thread. However, if you do so, you can NOT vote on the individual threads. And of course, the final vote will require its own thread.

 

 

 

 

Any questions, concerns, or objections? The voting should begin soon!



I made a bet with JoeTheBro on February 19, 2014. I say the 3DS will outsell the PS4 at least one month in 2014, he says the 3DS won't. Whoever is right gets to control the other person's sig for a month.

Check out Ohga Shrugs!

Love and tolerate.

Around the Network

Guess which one I'm voting for :P



KingdomHeartsFan said:

Guess which one I'm voting for :P

Hmmm Eternal Sonata ;D (I absolutely hate it)



Squeezol's Fanclub Member? is that how it works?

Why can't I hold all these no gaemz?

Always looking to improve my awful drawings ;_; 

Ok guys take your pick, who will win it all or the most Chrono Trigger or Final Fantasy VI? xD

painmaster212 said:
Ok guys take your pick, who will win it all or the most Chrono Trigger or Final Fantasy VI? xD

Im going with FFVI, gotta suplex a train :D



Squeezol's Fanclub Member? is that how it works?

Why can't I hold all these no gaemz?

Always looking to improve my awful drawings ;_; 

Around the Network
1) FFVII
2) Xenoblade
3) Earthbound
4) Tales of Vesperia
5) Bravely Default

                        Anime: Yuru Yuri                                                                                                             The Famous Club Co-Leader
                      
Haruhi Anime in English HD                                                                                          http://haruhi.com/
                      If you want to add me on WiiU/3ds                                                                            Just PM Me or Write on my Wall!

Ill edit mine once I can think of some:

Origins - Didn't play any games from this generation

Evolution - Final Fantasy VI 

Prominence - Final Fantasy VII (Also didn't play much for the first 3 generations)

Maturation - (1) Kingdom Hearts 2 (2) Ar Tonelico (3) Tales of the Abyss (4) Shin Megami Tensei: Nocturne (5) Odin Sphere

Modern - (1) Persona 4 Golden (2) Radiant Historia (3) Atelier Ayesha (4) Valkyria Chronicles (5) Tales of Xillia

Story - (1) Shin Megami Tensei IV (2) The Legend of Heroes: Trails in the Sky (3) 
Design - 
Gameplay - (1) Tales of Graces f (2) Valkyria Chronicles (3) Ys Memories of Celceta
Presentation - (1) Ni no Kuni (2) Ar Tonelico 2 (3) The World Ends with You
Influence - 
Multiplayer - 



Squeezol's Fanclub Member? is that how it works?

Why can't I hold all these no gaemz?

Always looking to improve my awful drawings ;_; 

Origins - Final Fantasy
Evolution - Final Fantasy 6
Prominence - Final Fantasy 7
Maturation - Final Fantasy X
Modern - Lame ass generation.. sadly. From what I played, "Tales of Vesperia"

Story - Final Fantasy 6
Gameplay - Final Fantasy 5
Presentation - Chrono Cross
Influence - Final Fantasy 4
Multiplayer - None. Tales of Vesperia MP looked fun but I didn't have a mate to play it with.



Behold!! The Edward Newgate Household!

http://s21.postimg.org/r6vbjpbh2/shekshi_desu.jpg

Kyuu said:

Modern - Lame ass generation.. sadly. From what I played, "Tales of Vesperia"

o.O surely this generation wasnt that bad for JRPGs, there are some amazing gems out there but my tastes might be different



Squeezol's Fanclub Member? is that how it works?

Why can't I hold all these no gaemz?

Always looking to improve my awful drawings ;_; 

Around the Network

Origins - Final Fantasy, The Magic of Scheherazade, Faxanadu, Dragon Warrior 3, Dragon Warrior 4,
Evolution - Final Fantasy 4, Final Fantasy 5, Final Fantasy 6, Chrono Trigger, Secret of Evermore
Prominence - Brigandine the Legend of Forsena, Brigandine Grand Edition, Arc the Lad 2, Tactics Ogre Let Us Cling Together, Grandia
Maturation - Wild ARMs 3, SMT Nocturne, SMT Digital Devil Saga, Castlevania Circle of the Moon, Phantasy Star Online
Modern - Tales of Graces F, SMT 4, Castlevania Dawn of Sorrow, Yakuza 4, Demon's Souls


Story - Xenogears, Tactics Ogre Let Us Cling Together, Xenosaga, SMT Nocturne, Persona 4.
Gameplay - Brigandine, Tactics Ogre, Arc the Lad 2, Wild ARMs 3, Final Fantasy 6.
Design - Wild ARMs 3, Xenogears, Final Fantasy 6, Dragon Warrior 7, Arc the Lad 2
Presentation - Final Fantasy 4 Complete Collection, Final Fantasy 6, Dragon's Crown, Chrono Trigger, White Knight Chronicles 2.
Influence - Final Fantasy 4(ATB,) Phantasy Star 4(team attacks,) Hydlide(first action RPG,) Digital Devil Story(first monster capturing game?,) and can't think of another.
Multiplayer - Tales of series, Brigandine Grand Edition, Arc Arena, White Knight Chronicles 2(which unfortunately no longer exists,) Phantasy Star Online. 

"Gameplay - Which games had the best overall design and world, from traversing the Earth to the nitty gritty puzzles."

Gameplay would be my top five games, but since most TRPGs don't have much of a world map or much design outside of combat, a few games would be excluded. Maybe you should break it up between gameplay and design. Gameplay being the games combat system, whatever customization is allowed, etc. Design should be world map design, dungeon design, puzzles, etc. I'm going to add it as a separate category and hope you add it.