Games are sometimes bad. Like really bad. But can criticism sometimes get out of control? Have some games been treated too harshly by gamers over the years?

Does Sonic 06 deserve quite as much hate as it receives? Was Halo Wars just too different from the rest of the series to be loved for what it was?

Final Fantasy XIII. I'm loving it so far.

Recently i would say Assassin's Creed Liberation HD

I'll say Metroid: Other M! Sure, the story was terrible but I don't really play Metroid games for the story. It did limit your exploration but so did Fusion and most people seem to like that one. I found the regular combat challenging which you can't really say about some of the others in the series. Having to hold up the Wii remote to charge your blaster really sucked though.

Well, I've always had a high tolerance with "worst games", so I'm cool with it :D

playstation all stars

Playstation All Stars + three buddies + alcohol = Awesome.

Every Dynasty Warriors ever.

Sonic 06 deserves it. It's pure broken crap. I've played Sonic 1, 3, CD, Knucles Kaotix, they are great games. I mean, all-time great games. The series was pure perfection. Sega destroyed it, made it mediocre. They murder Sonic and Altered Beast all the time. Well, at least After Burner, Outrun and Phantasy Star remain great.

More Sonic 06 crappiness: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WI0WX9me-3w

People will want to kill me here, but it is actually better than SSB Brawl. SSB 64 was the best ever, but the series simply destroyed their fast gameplay and PS All-Stars nailed that same fast gameplay I wanted on SSB. If SSB fans stopped bashing the game for being a ripoff and just looked at how it did a better gameplay, maybe the next SSB could become great again. Another Brawl style gameplay and I'm done with new SSBs and will just keep playing the 64 version.

Every main 3D Sonic since Sonic Heroes, including Shadow The Hedgehog.