Most overated game of all time. Previous winners were Metroid Prime and Super Mario Galaxy. Played TLOU for like 2-3 hours. The intro was outstanding. Then i started playing the game and was bored out of my mind. It plays like a broken Uncharted. I beat the first uncharted. Throught it was a good game, but nothing special. Played Uncharted 2 for 3-4 hours, stopped playing at Chapter 7. Felt it was too much like the first but with better graphics. Metroid Prime had a crappy story, a midi soundtrack, no voice acting, no multiplayer, tons of backtracking, fetch quests, and respawing enemies, and tank like controls. Super Mario Galaxy was a great game in terms of production values, but I found it to be a bit difficult and annoying at times. It was still a fun experience overall, but it does not deserve to be the highest ranked video game of all time. That title belongs to Zelda: Ocarina of Time. As for most underated games of all time:
Resident Evil Zero
Winback: Covert Operations
007: The World is Not Enough
Mission Impossible
Fighter's Destiny