i just saw the trailer for this game again and i must say, i liked it a lot better than the first time i saw it. The game looks like it will be a very solid and interesting one, So my prediction is that it will top any xbox one exclusive that released in 2014. so yes, i think it will score higher than Halo 5, Quantum Break and the Black Tusk game. 

More guessing than predicting :P And I never heard Black Tusk's game is releasing this year?

That'd be cool, it's got some tough competition with Halo and QB.

i like to take wild predictions, if i am right, i get to say "told you fuckers so!" if i dont, i eat crow xD but no worries i like the taste of crow  

will be eating some today since i made a wild prediction that PS4 will outsell Xb1 1.5:1 in dec NPD  

It looks interesting but i havent seen gamepaly. my main reason for being interested is it is insomniac. TitanFall, Halo, and Quantum Break will likely be the highest though. Sunset overdrive could be but im holding out on judgement until i see more.

I know nothing about black tusk's game including if it is in 2014 or 2015

no lol just no no nooooooo

I think Quantum Break could score the highest, but only if they master the whole split-story telling thing they have going on. It is a game that I think will either bomb, or be incredible.

Sunset Overdrive looked fun, but there is very little known about the game at the moment. Insomniac do have an impressive track record though so they might take the top spot.

Titanfall is also a contender. It is riding on a lot of hype at the moment, but it remains to be seen if it will live up to the expectations of the reviewers, and if those reviewing it will take it as it is or deduct points for the lack of single-player.

Halo games generally score high so there is a very real possibility that Halo will take the top spot, although it would definitely be very nice to see a new IP there!

http://www.metacritic.com/company/insomniac-games

If they return to the Insomniac games of the noughties, then possibly. Otherwise, I'd guess not. Although that massively depends if Halo 5 continues the downward trend and whether Quantum Break matches the hype or not.

I'm beginning to wonder if Sunset Overdrive will even release in 2014, too. Fuse & Ratchet: Nexus last year and not a gameplay trailer in sight of SO.

All I know is next year im going to have a ton a ganes to play that being one of them

i think their might be a chance halo 5 could be treated unfairly when it comes to reviews. Destiny is coming out in march and that game has been in development for about 5 years by then, it certainly seems like a VERY ambitious project and honestly it seems like a very awesome game. IF Destiny does deliver, i can see reviewers comparing halo 5 to destiny because of halo's past with bungie and they might not be fair to halo due to that comparison. of course, this is just a thought.