I agree that user scores are often better for judging a game than critic scores (once the fanboy flames die down) and I agree that Knack and Ryse didn't recieve as high of critic scores as I think they should have (I've heard mainly positive things from people I know who have played one or the other), but I have to disagree on DR3 being too high, I haven't heard anything about major bugs in DR3 (other than some framerate hiccups, which was to be expected given the number of Zombies on screen). As for KI, I think the reason that it got fairly high critic reviews despite being incomplete is because the critics acknowledged that it would be completed via DLC over the next few months, and deiced to review the game as if it were complete now, rather than re-review it in a few months (though a few of the critics have said that they will re-review it in a few months). 

2 of the 3 main exclusives got good scores, and 3 of the 6 minor exclusives got decent scores. It may not have been the best launch lineup ever, but it was one of the largest (with 3rd party included) and it was generally better than the PS4's launch lineup. 

It was a strange decision on their part. It'll be interesting to see what KI's final critic score is after the critics that plan to re-review it in a few months are averaged in, if the upcoming story mode and extra characters are good, it may even top 80, but if they suck it may drop below 70. 

78 average actually brings DR3 in behind DR1 and DR2, so I don't feel like it was overrated, since the main issue was with the game's performance. I watched Digital Foundry's performance review, I mainly only saw framerate drops when vehicles were plowing through large loads of zombies (lots of blood splatter effects) or when there were big explosions (a common cause of framerate drops in most games). A 16 FPS drop sounds bad for DR3, but if you watch framerate comparisons of Far Cry 3 on the 360 and PS3, it was known to drop that low, and yet it got a 90 on Metacritic. The thing with FPS drops is that some gamers simply don't notice them while playing, which likely accounts for why some reviewers didn't even note performance issues in their reviews. 

shikamaru317 said:

2 of the 3 main exclusives got good scores, and 3 of the 6 minor exclusives got decent scores. It may not have been the best launch lineup ever, but it was one of the largest (with 3rd party included) and it was generally better than the PS4's launch lineup.