You can say it however you like. As I said, considering how far down the list it is between critical reception and sales and that what is good or not is subjective, to say it as if the game is factually one of the best is silly.

As far as Quantum Break goes, it has potential but calling it the first true next-gen game is giving too much credit to a game we still don't know much about and there are games coming out before it that will likely beat it to the punch for that title.

Only thing silly is what you are saying. The game got good reviews across the board and as I said, the developer him self is saying the game was a success for them and that a sequel is coming.

What is a REAL next gen game??

OP still hasn't seen Driveclub or Shadowfall or Second Son or the Order, but it's okay only Xbox games look next gen to him apparently.

I would like to know that too.

1. Remedy isn't 1st party.

2. Respawn isn't 1st party.

3. Gears will most likely be multiplatform this gen, if the series continues.

4. Epic isn't 1st party. 

5. How do you know 1st party is the best it's ever been? Turn10 just pumped out it's worst game to date and it's top 3 microsoft studio, baseless assumptions much or blind optimism? 

What game is that in your sig?

New leaked gif of witcher 3 from gametrailers.

Remedy’s Sam Lake Details Quantum Break’s Transmedia Approach


http://www.gameinformer.com/b/news/archive/2013/11/22/remedy-s-sam-lake-details-quantum-break-s-transmedia-approach.aspx

You're forgetting digital sales though, also there was a Forza 3 + Alan Wake (digital) bundle so looking at the huge boost Forza 3 got we know Alan Wake has sold at least 2m - 2.5m on 360 alone. Then it was released on PC and has probably sold 0.5m - 1m, thus the 2.5m - 3.5m estimate is accurate.

Such a great game, it did well at around 3m but it's a shame it didn't do better, I want a sequel.