Forums - General Discussion - What Body Fat % is fat to you?

What's the highest % where a girl IS NOT FAT?

12%
15%
18%
20%
22%
25%
30%
35%
I'm a Chubby Chaser

Simple Question, with reference to the following images, when does someone look fat to you?

EDIT: The Poll asks the last % where a girl looks skinny, not the first level where she looks fat.

25% is winning, but I think most of you mean to say that 25% is where people start to look fat, not 25% still looks normal/skinny.


-------------------


------------------


------------------------


---------------



What is with all the hate? Don't read GamrReview Articles. Contact me to ADD games to the Database

Around the Network
soft core porn is not allowed on this site, reported
OT: according to those pics 30%

25-30

I voted 18%, which I think is a bit extreme, but I like girls skinny. The girl at 18% in the bottom right looks perfect to me, and 20% is great too, especially in the 2nd image, but it's boarderline for me. Still very attractive, but I would have to be very careful not to play with tummy fat on a girl who is 20% because girls are self concious, and I can't give the "Are you crazy? You think YOU'RE fat?" look to 20%

22% I consider fat, but since there are so many levels of overweight, I call 22%-25% curvy, 30% fat, 35% obese (which it probably is, since obesity is defined as a BMI of 30+), and above 45% scary.

----

I think I'm fair because while I consider 18% ideal for a girl, 12% looks ideal for a guy, and I would call a guy fatter with a lower BFP (%).



What is with all the hate? Don't read GamrReview Articles. Contact me to ADD games to the Database

Michael-5 said:

I voted 18%, which I think is a bit extreme, but I like girls skinny. The girl at 18% in the bottom right looks perfect to me, and 20% is great too, especially in the 2nd image, but it's boarderline for me. Still very attractive, but I would have to be very careful not to play with tummy fat on a girl who is 20% because girls are self concious, and I can't give the "Are you crazy? You think YOU'RE fat?" look to 20%

22% I consider fat, but since there are so many levels of overweight, I call 22%-25% curvy, 30% fat, 35% obese (which it probably is, since obesity is defined as a BMI of 30+), and above 45% scary.

----

I think I'm fair because while I consider 18% ideal for a girl, 12% looks ideal for a guy, and I would call a guy fatter with a lower BFP (%).

you must really like your girls starved



Around the Network
chapset said:
soft core porn is not allowed on this site, reported
OT: according to those pics 30%

Would this be soft core porn? There is no physical contact between two individuals, this is no different then going to the beach.

If I posted pictures of people making out, that would be soft core porn



What is with all the hate? Don't read GamrReview Articles. Contact me to ADD games to the Database

25 - 27 %.

Got big traps, lats and shounders, but thats about it.

Anything between 20-25 is fine for a girl. 



chapset said:
Michael-5 said:

I voted 18%, which I think is a bit extreme, but I like girls skinny. The girl at 18% in the bottom right looks perfect to me, and 20% is great too, especially in the 2nd image, but it's boarderline for me. Still very attractive, but I would have to be very careful not to play with tummy fat on a girl who is 20% because girls are self concious, and I can't give the "Are you crazy? You think YOU'RE fat?" look to 20%

22% I consider fat, but since there are so many levels of overweight, I call 22%-25% curvy, 30% fat, 35% obese (which it probably is, since obesity is defined as a BMI of 30+), and above 45% scary.

----

I think I'm fair because while I consider 18% ideal for a girl, 12% looks ideal for a guy, and I would call a guy fatter with a lower BFP (%).

you must really like your girls starved

I don't think 18% is starved, I think people in North America just got used to being "a little fat" and now normal weight = skinny. Like I said 20% looks alright to me, 22% is where I would start thinking they are chubby.

I think <15% is staved for women, and 15% is nice.

For men I think 5% and under is a bit gross, but 8% on a guy looks fine.

foodfather said:

25 - 27 %. 

Got big traps, lats and shounders, but thats about it.

Anything between 20-25 is fine for a girl. 

Muscle size/mass has nothing to do with body fat percentage. This isn't a BMI, but some mucle on people with BFP 20% or less makes a world of difference in terms of attrativeness.



What is with all the hate? Don't read GamrReview Articles. Contact me to ADD games to the Database

Wtf, the 30% girl here does not look like the other 30% girls. She doesn't look fat at all. Not even chubby. 

There are more inconsistensies in the different pictures. I would say 30-35% is where they start looking a bit on the fat side



Watch this space - counting down to the GOTG soon

Around the Network
Michael-5 said:

I voted 18%, which I think is a bit extreme, but I like girls skinny. The girl at 18% in the bottom right looks perfect to me, and 20% is great too, especially in the 2nd image, but it's boarderline for me. Still very attractive, but I would have to be very careful not to play with tummy fat on a girl who is 20% because girls are self concious, and I can't give the "Are you crazy? You think YOU'RE fat?" look to 20%

22% I consider fat, but since there are so many levels of overweight, I call 22%-25% curvy, 30% fat, 35% obese (which it probably is, since obesity is defined as a BMI of 30+), and above 45% scary.

----

I think I'm fair because while I consider 18% ideal for a girl, 12% looks ideal for a guy, and I would call a guy fatter with a lower BFP (%).

You voted 18% yet you think 30% is when they start to look fat? Aren't you going against your own question?



Watch this space - counting down to the GOTG soon