ITT: People judging an entire game based on 1 min of gameplay. I'm going to at least try it out at Best Buy before I make any conclusions.

You are going to judge from a 5min demo. It is basically the same.

@F0X

The trailer gave me the impression that levels are going to be big. Or at least I hope so. I guess no hub again this time... I enjoyed Peach's Castle, Delfino Plaza and Rosalina's Comet.

I sort of got the same impression.

Hub worlds are fun, but I also liked NSMBU's world map. Hopefully SM3DW will live up to the "World" name.

Oh man...this is just sad.

This game seems just too "cute". Yellow cat suit? C'mon! I know Mario has always been cute and colorful but this just seems too much. Nintendo should be trying to change their image to get the so called "core gamers". Look at the Microsoft and Sony presentations and the trailers they showed, a lot of dark tones, somber situations, drama. I personally don't care for that but that is the audience Nintendo lost a long time ago and who they were trying to get back with the WiiU.

Mario was suppose to show the world that the WiiU is the system to get. The game should had showed the best graphics possible in the WiiU, the innovative use of the Gamepad.

I can now bet that WiiU will not make a come back.

So experiencing the game is the same as watching a promo strip?

@Venepe: The only people who demand every game be an edgy game are people who technically aren't allowed to buy them.  Mature content is fine, but forcing it on light-hearted series isn't necessary.  I thought we'd moved past this years ago.

Obviously not, and clearly regarding gameplay you'll have a handicap over us who are not going to experience, but to judge the game we need to play completly, or at least the majority of it, not only a demo.

Presentation is enough in a vid. Soundtrack until the final game is released.

I didn't say I was going to review the game, just decide whether it "looks garbage" or whether it looks like it could be fun.

Guess I have to make it clear that I don't agree with the game looking like garbage, but being dissapointed considering the 3D Mario standars.

And my point is that I don't feel like a short promo reel is enough to say something is disappointing or not, especially when it comes to a series like 3D Mario.

I have absolutely no desir to play the game even for 5 :minutes to try, I am very pissed for what they did to their flagship title.