By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Politics Discussion - Tax Junk Food/Regulate Contents?

Tagged games:

 

Tax Food with high concentrations of Salt/Fat/Sugar/HFCS?

Yes, tax anything high fat 7 12.28%
 
Yes, tax anything high salt 0 0%
 
Yes, tax anything high sugar 1 1.75%
 
Yes, tax anything with HFCS 0 0%
 
Yes, tax a combination of... 5 8.77%
 
Yes tax all of the above 10 17.54%
 
Maybe, not sure 0 0%
 
No, just lift the Corn Subsidy 12 21.05%
 
No, we can read a nutrition label fine 16 28.07%
 
See Results 4 7.02%
 
Total:55
PureDante said:
Mr Puggsly said:
Tax being a fat fuck.


This. Tax irresponsibility. 


Life's hard. But it's harder when you're stupid.  



Around the Network
Michael-5 said:

This is completly false. A Big Mac Combo is about $7 and that barely feeds 1 person for 1 day. I live off $20 a week for food (I cook a lot), and I can tell you that you can feed a person for about $2 a day no problem. Eating healthy is cheaper then eating crap.


I feed my self AND  my gf for $30 a week and we eat better than a 5 star restaurant.  Everything from scratch.  Pancakes n stuff in the morning,  pizza from scratch, gas grilling, roasting, deep frying, I make my own ice cream!  The stuff I make is not enumurable.  But here's the kicker.  It doesnt take time or hardwork, it takes brains.  I can whip up the most amazing food faster than a trip through the drive through.  Ppl that think they have to read labels need to start reading the recipes on the web. Am I right?



snyps said:
Michael-5 said:

This is completly false. A Big Mac Combo is about $7 and that barely feeds 1 person for 1 day. I live off $20 a week for food (I cook a lot), and I can tell you that you can feed a person for about $2 a day no problem. Eating healthy is cheaper then eating crap.


I feed my self AND  my gf for $30 a week and we eat better than a 5 star restaurant.  Everything from scratch.  Pancakes n stuff in the morning,  pizza from scratch, gas grilling, roasting, deep frying, I make my own ice cream!  The stuff I make is not enumurable.  But here's the kicker.  It doesnt take time or hardwork, it takes brains.  I can whip up the most amazing food faster than a trip through the drive through.  Ppl that think they have to read labels need to start reading the recipes on the web. Am I right?

Ok i gotta ask what you are eating to get by that cheap.  My fiance and I eat very healthy food as well and i live in a cheap part of the US but i have to pay $50-$60 per week for the 2 of us.  We don't eat a heck of a lot, we're both fairly skinny.  I don't see any way i could cut the amount we spend in half without going to a ridiculously basic diet of rice, beans, and nuts or something.



currently playing: Skyward Sword, Mario Sunshine, Xenoblade Chronicles X

NO NO NO NO NO NO NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!

We need less government interference not more. What kind of a country do you want to live in? I prefer the kind with real freedom and liberty. Taxation is just another form of control. If I had my way the only thing taxed would be income and it would be a flat 10% for everyone no matter what. No loopholes and no way out of it. If you make a dollar you pay 10cents. that's it. But if I had my way the government would be a lot smaller and spend less so we probably wouldn't even need a 10% tax.

Drop all subsidies, get rid of nanny laws and taxes, and go back to the basics of government.



Michael-5 said:
Weedlab said:

Well, there are many negative consequences related to people's bad eating habits, and unfortunately they can be externalized. Contrary to what some of them may think, their actions do affect others when you look at things at the macro level. I believe that is part of the reason for this ban in the first place. However, I do not support coercing people to do the 'right thing'. From my experience it just doesn't work. People need to discover legitimate reasons on their accord.

I used to consume copious amounts of the stuff when I was in undergrad, and then I was hit with acid reflux. That was the start of other health issues. I traced everything back to my diet and through trial and error I learned what was best for me. Now I do not consume any form of junk food - nothing processed, no fizzy drinks, and I check the label on everything I eat. If I can't pronounce it then I don't bother with it. That's just one example. Most people I know respond to incentives like what I mentioned, but coercion usually brings about the opposite effect.

You do realize that Americans have an obesity rate of 33%? This is nearly 3x the Obesity rate in Germany, nearly 4x the obesity rate of Itally and over 10x the obesity rate of South Koreans and Japanese.

People (specifically Americans, Canadians, English, and Australians) can't discover legitimate reasons to eat healthy on their own.

Wouldn't it be better if you never had that acid refluc in the first place? If food, all food, had more reasonable portions of fat, sugar, and salt, you'd probably be a lot better off. I don't think the best way to stay healthy is for people to get obese and then realize their mistakes. It's better to not make those mistakes at all.

After all, everything is moderation, except moderation itself, is a good thing right? So why not moderate addatives in food?

Weedlab said:
Oh and ... personally, I think instead of implementing a ban focus should be placed on the type of foods available. Calories are cheap, but nutrition is expensive. People often complain about eating right because it is too expensive, especially when you can buy enough food to feed a family for under 10 USD in McDonalds. The gov should focus on making the 'right' food cheaper - be it through subsidies or other means.

This is completly false. A Big Mac Combo is about $7 and that barely feeds 1 person for 1 day. I live off $20 a week for food (I cook a lot), and I can tell you that you can feed a person for about $2 a day no problem. Eating healthy is cheaper then eating crap.

Yes it would have been better if I didn’t have it in the first place, but only in an ideal world. Hardships are necessary to encourage progression, and having acid reflux was no different. It turned me into a conscious consumer with respect to eating, and now I can pass on what I learned to help others. The great majority of people do not alter things unless they hit a critical point. That’s why I believe in incentives and disincentives. I only gave ONE example for how incentives works, and it was a personal experience. I had a health related incentive to change.

People are very ignorant and choose to stay ignorant. In this sense I believe the government should step in, but not with bans or anything coercive (back to incentives and disincentives). Give people an inventive to eat right and disincentives to eating poorly. Where I live taxes are considerably lower on green vehicles and light bulbs than on regular cars and the conventional light bulbs. As a result, people responded and bought more of the former. Telling them it is better for the environment or that it would save them more in the long run did very little, but the tax incentives helped tremendously. Again, just an example, but the concept is much broader.

Are you aware of the Big Mac Index and what it does? Okay … it may be relatively expensive where YOU live, but where I live it is VERY cheap. The cost of a meal from McDonalds is relative from place to place, and the combinations people employ are much different from what you think the average person may buy. I've seen people buy apple pies and a dollar burger for instance. This also extends to healthier foods. It may be relatively cheap where you live, but that doesn't suggest it is cheap in other places. And as I stated before calories (junk food in general) is much cheaper than nutrition, so it’s part of the reason why people consume them. By junk I’m not solely referring to fast food, but cheap processed food you find in the supermarket for next to nothing. I’m not suggesting all health food items are expensive since some are cheap, and I think this goes back to ignorance. People need to be conscious of the cheap healthy foods available. A lot of people are unaware of things like yams, beets and other unconventional foods.

Moderate additives in foods? Could you elaborate here? I don’t want to assume, but if it is what I think you are suggesting then I’m not sure I’d support that notion. My first degree is in nutrition, and I know the unintended health consequences that can bring.





 

Playstation = The Beast from the East

Sony + Nintendo = WIN! PS3 + PSV + PS4 + Wii U + 3DS


Around the Network

why even tax...just regulate the amount of shit in this garbage. its already done with countless other ingredients that have been deemed unsafe at certain levels.  these foods literally become addictive to people because of all the filth in them.  



"I like my steaks how i like my women.  Bloody and all over my face"

"Its like sex, but with a winner!"

MrBubbles Review Threads: Bill Gates, Jak II, Kingdom Hearts II, The Strangers, Sly 2, Crackdown, Zohan, Quarantine, Klungo Sssavesss Teh World, MS@E3'08, WATCHMEN(movie), Shadow of the Colossus, The Saboteur

snyps said:
Michael-5 said:

This is completly false. A Big Mac Combo is about $7 and that barely feeds 1 person for 1 day. I live off $20 a week for food (I cook a lot), and I can tell you that you can feed a person for about $2 a day no problem. Eating healthy is cheaper then eating crap.


I feed my self AND  my gf for $30 a week and we eat better than a 5 star restaurant.  Everything from scratch.  Pancakes n stuff in the morning,  pizza from scratch, gas grilling, roasting, deep frying, I make my own ice cream!  The stuff I make is not enumurable.  But here's the kicker.  It doesnt take time or hardwork, it takes brains.  I can whip up the most amazing food faster than a trip through the drive through.  Ppl that think they have to read labels need to start reading the recipes on the web. Am I right?

I'm not as extreme as you, I don't make my own ice cream, and sometimes I get expensive stuff (like pine nuts) to make food taste really special, but yea I agree wiith you 100%. I can't eat pasta sauce from a can anymore, and my deep fried fish is just as good as a restaurants (except smaller chunks because I don't have a deep frier).

The problem with people eating like us though is lazyness. People are too lazy to look up a recipe and spend 20-30 minutes cooking and cleaning. It's easier to sit in a car and drive to McDonalds, and fast food chains take advantage of that lazyness.

johnsobas said:

Ok i gotta ask what you are eating to get by that cheap.  My fiance and I eat very healthy food as well and i live in a cheap part of the US but i have to pay $50-$60 per week for the 2 of us.  We don't eat a heck of a lot, we're both fairly skinny.  I don't see any way i could cut the amount we spend in half without going to a ridiculously basic diet of rice, beans, and nuts or something.

It depends on what type of food you eat. If you eat just pasta/rice/potato dishes, make your own sauces, and add vegetables, you can easily feed the both of you for $30 comined a week. I feed my girlfriend a lot, and yea.

If you eat a lot of meat, then things get a lot more expensive. I only eat meat about once a week, but I substitue the protein with lots of eggs, beans and some nuts.

Also $30 a week is true only if you cook everything you eat from scratch. I've recently been buying yogurt, and snack food like that brings the price of living up, but it's nice to have something which isn't a fruit, immediatly available, and I don't always want to make a salad.

P.S. A salad takes what 2-3 minutes to make? That's faster then the line at fast food, and with crutons, tomatos, and cucumbers, it's still only about $2 for a large salad in cost.



What is with all the hate? Don't read GamrReview Articles. Contact me to ADD games to the Database
Vote for the March Most Wanted / February Results

kain_kusanagi said:
NO NO NO NO NO NO NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!

We need less government interference not more. What kind of a country do you want to live in? I prefer the kind with real freedom and liberty. Taxation is just another form of control. If I had my way the only thing taxed would be income and it would be a flat 10% for everyone no matter what. No loopholes and no way out of it. If you make a dollar you pay 10cents. that's it. But if I had my way the government would be a lot smaller and spend less so we probably wouldn't even need a 10% tax.

Drop all subsidies, get rid of nanny laws and taxes, and go back to the basics of government.


You sound like a pupil of Milton Friedman lol



 

Playstation = The Beast from the East

Sony + Nintendo = WIN! PS3 + PSV + PS4 + Wii U + 3DS


kain_kusanagi said:
NO NO NO NO NO NO NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!

We need less government interference not more. What kind of a country do you want to live in? I prefer the kind with real freedom and liberty. Taxation is just another form of control. If I had my way the only thing taxed would be income and it would be a flat 10% for everyone no matter what. No loopholes and no way out of it. If you make a dollar you pay 10cents. that's it. But if I had my way the government would be a lot smaller and spend less so we probably wouldn't even need a 10% tax.

Drop all subsidies, get rid of nanny laws and taxes, and go back to the basics of government.

If we all only paid 10% tax, then Doctors, and Landlords would just be accumulating wealth at ridiculous rates. If you were born into a rich family, own a large company, or just make a lot of $$$ you also have a higher responsibility to the poor. You already have mega-corporations in USA, Wal-Mart grosses more then Poland in a year, do the Waltons and Bill Gates really need billions of dollars? No.

Weedlab said:
Michael-5 said:
Weedlab said:

Well, there are many negative consequences related to people's bad eating habits, and unfortunately they can be externalized. Contrary to what some of them may think, their actions do affect others when you look at things at the macro level. I believe that is part of the reason for this ban in the first place. However, I do not support coercing people to do the 'right thing'. From my experience it just doesn't work. People need to discover legitimate reasons on their accord.

I used to consume copious amounts of the stuff when I was in undergrad, and then I was hit with acid reflux. That was the start of other health issues. I traced everything back to my diet and through trial and error I learned what was best for me. Now I do not consume any form of junk food - nothing processed, no fizzy drinks, and I check the label on everything I eat. If I can't pronounce it then I don't bother with it. That's just one example. Most people I know respond to incentives like what I mentioned, but coercion usually brings about the opposite effect.

You do realize that Americans have an obesity rate of 33%? This is nearly 3x the Obesity rate in Germany, nearly 4x the obesity rate of Itally and over 10x the obesity rate of South Koreans and Japanese.

People (specifically Americans, Canadians, English, and Australians) can't discover legitimate reasons to eat healthy on their own.

Wouldn't it be better if you never had that acid refluc in the first place? If food, all food, had more reasonable portions of fat, sugar, and salt, you'd probably be a lot better off. I don't think the best way to stay healthy is for people to get obese and then realize their mistakes. It's better to not make those mistakes at all.

After all, everything is moderation, except moderation itself, is a good thing right? So why not moderate addatives in food?

Weedlab said:
Oh and ... personally, I think instead of implementing a ban focus should be placed on the type of foods available. Calories are cheap, but nutrition is expensive. People often complain about eating right because it is too expensive, especially when you can buy enough food to feed a family for under 10 USD in McDonalds. The gov should focus on making the 'right' food cheaper - be it through subsidies or other means.

This is completly false. A Big Mac Combo is about $7 and that barely feeds 1 person for 1 day. I live off $20 a week for food (I cook a lot), and I can tell you that you can feed a person for about $2 a day no problem. Eating healthy is cheaper then eating crap.

 

 

 

Yes it would have been better if I didn’t have it in the first place, but only in an ideal world. Hardships are necessary to encourage progression, and having acid reflux was no different. It turned me into a conscious consumer with respect to eating, and now I can pass on what I learned to help others. The great majority of people do not alter things unless they hit a critical point. That’s why I believe in incentives and disincentives. I only gave ONE example for how incentives works, and it was a personal experience. I had a health related incentive to change.

People are very ignorant and choose to stay ignorant. In this sense I believe the government should step in, but not with bans or anything coercive (back to incentives and disincentives). Give people inventive to eat right and disincentives to eating poorly. Where I live taxes on green vehicles are considerably lower on green vehicles and light bulbs than regular cars and the conventional light bulbs. As a result, people responded and bought more of the former. Telling them it is better for the environment or that it would save them more in the long run did very little, but the tax incentive helped tremendously. Again, just an example, but the concept is much broader.

Are you aware of the Big Mac Index and what it does? Okay … it may be relatively expensive where YOU live, but where I live it is VERY cheap. The cost of a meal from McDonalds is relative from place to place, and the combinations people employ are much different from what you think the average person may buy. I've seen people buy apple pies and a dollar burger for instance. This also extends to healthier foods. It may be relatively cheap where you live, but that doesn't suggest it is cheap in other places. And as I stated before calories (junk food in general) is much cheaper than nutrition, so it’s part of the reason why people consume them. By junk I’m not solely referring to fast food, but cheap processed food you find in the supermarket for next to nothing. I’m not suggesting all health food items are expensive since some are cheap, and I think this goes back to ignorance. People need to be conscious of the cheap health foods available. A lot of people are unaware of things like yams, beets and other unconventional foods.

Moderate additives in foods? Could you elaborate here? I don’t want to assume, but if it is what I think you are suggesting then I’m not sure I’d support that notion. My first degree is in nutrition, and I know the unintended health consequences that can bring.

 

Hardships are necessary to encourage progression, you do realize that obesity rates have doubled in the last 20 years right? Food Quality has been going downhill in North America since the 70's and the main reason is to cut costs so large company's make more $$$.

If you're making a case about incentives, I agree with you. We should reduce taxes on healthy foods (Produce has no tax in Canada), and increase taxes on junky food. That's my arguement.

Potatos and rice are two of the cheapest sources of carbs, they are cheaper then corn products, and much healthier. We could easily make sugar from beats (They use beat sugar in pops in Europe), and it would be a lot cheaper and healthier then corn products. Yes carbs in general are cheap, but we do need to make standards. My arguement isn't to get people to eat more nutritious food, just to push company's to make less junky foods. If we say remove the corn subsidy, HFCS and thus candy/pop will become more expensive. However if a compeditor came in am made a product with beat sugar, he could sell the healthier product for less. Win Win.

Plus, if we take junky foods because they have too much fat in them, we could also give a tax break (an incentive) on healthy foods. Crackers and humus cost about as much as chips, but they don't have their own Aile in grocery stores. If chips became more expensive, people would eat more crackers.

As for moderating addatives in food, salt is a good example. Adding salt to subway sandwiches, McDonalds Fries, or pizza doesn't alter the taste that much. In fact a lot of Europeaners can't stand our food because it's so damn salty, and there rarely is a no salt option. If you taxed foods with high salt, people would stop putting them on pre-cooked foods (or at least give you the no salt option, like at McDonalds), and this would be an immediate health benefit. To give you an example of how much salt there is in food, 2-3 slices of pizza cover 1 adult males entire daily salt intake.

Plus there is no reason to cook our food in so much fat, to the point where paper bags become clear.



What is with all the hate? Don't read GamrReview Articles. Contact me to ADD games to the Database
Vote for the March Most Wanted / February Results

Michael-5 said:
snyps said:
Michael-5 said:

This is completly false. A Big Mac Combo is about $7 and that barely feeds 1 person for 1 day. I live off $20 a week for food (I cook a lot), and I can tell you that you can feed a person for about $2 a day no problem. Eating healthy is cheaper then eating crap.


I feed my self AND  my gf for $30 a week and we eat better than a 5 star restaurant.  Everything from scratch.  Pancakes n stuff in the morning,  pizza from scratch, gas grilling, roasting, deep frying, I make my own ice cream!  The stuff I make is not enumurable.  But here's the kicker.  It doesnt take time or hardwork, it takes brains.  I can whip up the most amazing food faster than a trip through the drive through.  Ppl that think they have to read labels need to start reading the recipes on the web. Am I right?

I'm not as extreme as you, I don't make my own ice cream, and sometimes I get expensive stuff (like pine nuts) to make food taste really special, but yea I agree wiith you 100%. I can't eat pasta sauce from a can anymore, and my deep fried fish is just as good as a restaurants (except smaller chunks because I don't have a deep frier).

The problem with people eating like us though is lazyness. People are too lazy to look up a recipe and spend 20-30 minutes cooking and cleaning. It's easier to sit in a car and drive to McDonalds, and fast food chains take advantage of that lazyness.

johnsobas said:

Ok i gotta ask what you are eating to get by that cheap.  My fiance and I eat very healthy food as well and i live in a cheap part of the US but i have to pay $50-$60 per week for the 2 of us.  We don't eat a heck of a lot, we're both fairly skinny.  I don't see any way i could cut the amount we spend in half without going to a ridiculously basic diet of rice, beans, and nuts or something.

It depends on what type of food you eat. If you eat just pasta/rice/potato dishes, make your own sauces, and add vegetables, you can easily feed the both of you for $30 comined a week. I feed my girlfriend a lot, and yea.

If you eat a lot of meat, then things get a lot more expensive. I only eat meat about once a week, but I substitue the protein with lots of eggs, beans and some nuts.

Also $30 a week is true only if you cook everything you eat from scratch. I've recently been buying yogurt, and snack food like that brings the price of living up, but it's nice to have something which isn't a fruit, immediatly available, and I don't always want to make a salad.

P.S. A salad takes what 2-3 minutes to make? That's faster then the line at fast food, and with crutons, tomatos, and cucumbers, it's still only about $2 for a large salad in cost.

i still couldn't do that.  We basically get mostly veggies, then some potatoes, 1 kind of fruit, frozen chicken, milk, eggs, one kind of beans.  I'm already well over $30 at that point.  Then there are all kinds of other expenses though, like honey, rice, cooking oil, spices, yeast, flour.  Nothing is packaged, everything is cooked fresh from the sauces to the bread.  I would say my diet is very basic, i avoid all of the expensive veggies and fruit.  I only eat the frozen chicken which is barely over $2 a pound. 



currently playing: Skyward Sword, Mario Sunshine, Xenoblade Chronicles X